Manhattan Kosher Restaurants

[Dan]

I don't understand why people like Abagael so much. It reminds me of my school cafeteria.

+1

[mochjas]

I don't understand why people like Abagael so much. It reminds me of my school cafeteria.

maybe you don't know what to get

[Dan]

maybe you don't know what to get

Got the pastrami egg roll, was frozen inside, they said that's how it's supposed to come.

[mochjas]

Got the pastrami egg roll, was frozen inside, they said that's how it's supposed to come.

thats 1 item. I reviewed them above in this thread and I go a bunch there for lunch. The food is consistently good. And a great value at lunch.

[mochjas]

Got the pastrami egg roll, was frozen inside, they said that's how it's supposed to come.

and I don't believe that they have a pastrami egg roll

[palm tights]

maybe you don't know what to get

I tried it in the summer for my first time and had a real bad experience and the food is really bland nothing special ,we tried many dishes ,the only thing that i always think about is the huuugge sundea ice cream dessert ,but in taste my local ice cream shop makes it better ,just the idea makes me wow ,its really big 😂

And the service was bad i asked for chicken soup and waiter said they have with vegetables and some spices , it was actually a hot spicy tomato yemenite soup with a few pieces of chicken and vegetables ,was really gross , if i am not mistaken it was mainly heated up tomato soup , and the old fashioned soggy crackers with spicy tomatoes that welcomes you on the table is a bad first impression and not good as well.

Ach

[palm tights]

and I don't believe that they have a pastrami egg roll

They do have a pastrami eggroll ,the only thing that was edible but i know a few fast food stores that makes it much better

[palm tights]

thats 1 item. I reviewed them above in this thread and I go a bunch there for lunch. The food is consistently good. And a great value at lunch.

Great value for lunch menu is totally different then fine dining that its really not worth and nothing to eat special

[mochjas]

They do have a pastrami eggroll ,the only thing that was edible but i know a few fast food stores that makes it much better

dont  see it on the menu and don't remember ever seeing it

[palm tights]

font see it on the menu and don't remember ever seeing it

It probably have a different name if i remember good

All thier food was on the spicy side ,not sure how old school people are liking that

[mochjas]

I tried it in the summer for my first time and had a real bad experience and the food is really bland nothing special ,we tried many dishes ,the only thing that i always think about is the huuugge sundea ice cream dessert ,but in taste my local ice cream shop makes it better ,just the idea makes me wow ,its really big 😂

And the service was bad i asked for chicken soup and waiter said they have with vegetables and some spices , it was actually a hot spicy tomato yemenite soup with a few pieces of chicken and vegetables ,was really gross , if i am not mistaken it was mainly heated up tomato soup , and the old fashioned soggy crackers with spicy tomatoes that welcomes you on the table is a bad first impression and not good as well.

Ach

listen I'm not saying it is reserve cut level but it's definitely the next level below on par with le marais and I prefer it to Le marais as they have more appetizers and more choices. Is every dish always perfect? No but I've had several dinners and A lot of lunches here and it is very consistent for me

[palm tights]

The huge sundea

Actually this is what you can see that back in the days when abegails was one of the only steakhouses when they newly opened ,you can now understand that the kosher scene uped the game tremendously,  same goes with le marais was the subpar kosher steakhouse and now its meh , times changing,  wonder how many of the old school restaurants will survive in tri state area with so much new and really great restaurants in the scene.

[palm tights]

listen I'm not saying it is reserve cut level but it's definitely the next level below on par with le marais and I prefer it to Le marais as they have more appetizers and more choices. Is every dish always perfect? No but I've had several dinners and A lot of lunches here and it is very consistent for me

Well Mr. Broadway down the block i would rate atleast 10 times better ,not to compare at all

I am not sure where you have eaten besides abegails but we spent over there a fortune and honestly no dish that was even just tasty or good ,let alone something to wow . My point is for such expensive prices its nothing worth

[mochjas]

Well Mr. Broadway down the block i would rate atleast 10 times better ,not to compare at all

I am not sure where you have eaten besides abegails but we spent over there a fortune and honestly no dish that was even just tasty or good ,let alone something to wow . My point is for such expensive prices its nothing worth

ok now I know you are nuts if you think mr broadway is 10 times better than Abigaels. Mr broadway can't even get a sandwich right.

[palm tights]

ok now I know you are nuts if you think mr broadway is 10 times better than Abigaels. Mr broadway can't even get a sandwich right.

I was at mr broadway fine dinning 2 times past couple of weeks and they beat alot of restaurants with their food ,the ambiance is not reserve cut  ,
They brought back the veal ribs on the menu ,u can't get it anywhere and its delicious,  price wise is Mr. Broadway worth it much more then many restaurants.
And btw for a reason they are always packed out the door with no seating at any night.

[mochjas]

I was at mr broadway fine dinning 2 times past couple of weeks and they beat alot of restaurants with their food ,the ambiance is not reserve cut  ,
They brought back the veal ribs on the menu ,u can't get it anywhere and its delicious,  price wise is Mr. Broadway worth it much more then many restaurants.
And btw for a reason they are always packed out the door with no seating at any night.

the reason they are packed is bec they are quick and on the cheaper side for kosher. Fine dining and mr. Broadway do not belong in the same sentence

[palm tights]

Mr. Braodway


Just for the Pickels and cole slaw is even worth to go to them 😂

There chicken soup is one of the best hearthy chicken soups u can get in nyc (i ordered broth only ,no matza ball or noddeles) actually i wonder why dosent every restaurant have a hearthy chicken aoup without chemicals
Pastrami empandas on gucamole , was really good , it comes 3 pieces

Half smoked chicken that was really good ,intresting for a change to eat chicken

Veal ribs

[palm tights]

the reason they are packed is bec they are quick and on the cheaper side for kosher. Fine dining and mr. Broadway do not belong in the same sentence

Look the fine dining dinner menu, not really cheaper then abigails

[Z56]

Which restaurant was this ?

[aygart]

Those veal ribs look so old they could have grandchildren.