Topic Wiki

Venice Overview
Venice is a gorgeous and romantic city that doesn't disappoint. It's a fantastic place to spend Shabbos because there are several points hotel options, a Chabad with several meal options, the ability to carry and because the biggest attraction of Venice - just simply walking the streets and bridges - is a perfect Shabbos activity which will keep you from just be sitting bored in a hotel room.

Trip Reports:
Dan, Avid Reader, MnM1130, ChAiM'l, aj26, Yosers1, jj1000, Hudi, Cbs, Eli, steve L, jmansour, VacationLover, Yehoshua, Mech, yg99, yls2011, ABC, AharonInIsrael, @Yehuda, shlonx  dvol, @Mootkim,Sam28,

Getting there and getting around:

How long should I go for?
There really aren't too many activities to do in Venice, so a 1-2 day trip could cover the must see/do sights, but the city is so beautiful that you won't regret a longer stay! Because the sights are mostly just walking around the streets, checking out the shops, etc. many people find spending just a Shabbos/weekend in Venice is enough to get their fill. Arrive on a Friday and leave Sunday evening and you'll get your fill. (Again, a longer stay rocks too!)

Travelling around Italy/Getting to Venice
Most often, if you're making a trip from USA to Venice, you're not just going to see Venice, but rather a few cities in Italy. When visiting Italy there are a few ways to travel around - trains, rent a car, or if you're going directly from one end of Italy (let's say Rome) to the other end (let's say Milan or Venice), it could be you'll want to fly.

Air:
If Venice is your first stop in Italy, then you'll likely be coming via air. VCE is the airport code, and the airport is not actually in Venice proper (no, the planes don't land in the canals). Rather, you'll have to take a water bus or water taxi from the airport to Venice proper. The water buses to/from the airport are run by a company called Alilaguna (buses here aren't run by the city), take around an hour to get to San Marco Square (the main points hotel location) and cost 14euro. You can buy a roundtrip in advance for 25euro. Private water taxis take around 1/2 hour, but are a lot more expensive. Because people arrive at VCE from many different locations, it's not practical to discuss the different routes you can take to get here.

Train:
If your Italy trip starts in a different city in Italy, then you may want to look into travelling via rail. There are 2 main train companies in Italy - TrenItalia and Treno Italo. Rates vary on a bunch of factors and neither site is fantastically designed, so check them out and ask for some help here if you need. Alternatively you can use loco2.com which is an easy to use site all in English it has all the options and they don’t charge anybooking fees. The express train Rome-Venice takes about 3:45 hours and the overnight takes 5.5-6.5 hours. As opposed to the airport, St. Lucia Train Station is actually in Venice proper. Once you arrive, you can take a Vaporetto to your desired location (again, likely San Marco Square). See "Getting around Venice" below for Vaporetto prices. You can also take a private water taxi, which won't have any stops, but will cost a lot more.

Car Rental:
If your Italy trip starts in a different city in Italy, then besides for taking trains, you may find that a car rental suits your needs better, especially if you plan on hitting up several cities along the way as taking a train usually means having to get a cab or bus to/from each train station from your hotel. That time/cost plus the cost of the trains may cause you to decide on a car rental instead. Since it's Europe, expect a manual car unless you pay more for an automatic. Driving in Italy may bother you if you're not super comfortable driving, but in terms of driving in Venice, don't be concerned. You'll be coming from a highway (which is just like highway driving back home), you'll get off onto normal sized/paved roads and within a few minutes, will likely be at your car rental dropoff - outside of Venice proper. There are no cars in Venice (although there is a Hertz in Venice proper that you could actually drive to and drop your car off, but rates at that location are super expensive), so you will likely drop your car off near the Venice-Mestre Train Station - not the St. Lucia station that's actually in Venice - but a second train station that's just outside Venice proper. From Mestre station, a 10 minute, 2 euro train ride will get you into St. Lucia station and from there you can follow the options listed above to get to your hotel.

Getting around Venice
If you're staying in the Jewish Ghetto or near San Marco Square (we'll get to where to stay soon), you'll be within walking distance (max 1/2 hour) of all the main sites in Venice. Even still, many people like to take a public water bus, known as a Vaporetto, to travel down the canals. You can buy tickets at many Vaparetto stops. An individual one way ride costs 7 euro, but there are also 24/48/72 hour passes that cost 20/30/40 euro, respectively. If you're between the ages of 14-29, you can buy a 72 hour Youth Pass for just 20 euro. It's possible that you may need to first purchase a "Rolling Venice" guidebook (should be available at the ticket counter) for 4 euro before they'll let you buy the Youth pass, but you can find that out at the ticket counter and even 24 euro is a great deal. There's also a special roundtrip beach ticket to Lido that costs 10 euro. Do some math to see what kind of pass will work best for you.


Where to stay:

There are 2 main areas where people normally stay: 1) The Jewish Ghetto, which is where the Shuls/restaurants are, as well as some Kosher hotels, but no points hotels and 2) San Marco Square, about a 1/2 hour walk from the Ghetto, but where most of the points hotels are. The walk is very nice, and helps you accomplish the "activity" of seeing the streets while on the way to your destination. The 30 minute walk may hinder your desire to make it to Shul for all Tefillos. YMMV ;)

Here are some places that are discussed in this thread:

NameAreaMore InfoComments
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Pardes RimonimJewish GhettoWebsiteKosher hotel
Carnival Place<10 minute walk to the GhettoWebsiteNicest hotel near the Ghetto
Locanda Del GhettoJewish GhettoWebsiteKosher hotel
Westin Europa and ReginaSan Marco SquareWebsiteSPG Cat. 6; 20-25K/night. Beautiful hotel with marble lobby and a luxurious feel.
Comfort Hotel DianaSan Marco SquareWebsite10K Choice/night. Definitely dated, but kinda rustic in that regard. Cheapest points hotel option in the points hotel-lacking city of Venice.
Grand Hotel Dei Dogi, Autograph Collection<10 minute walk to the GhettoWebsite45K Marriott/night.
JW Marriott Venice Resort & SpaNOT able to walk to the Ghetto, But Free ShuttleWebsite40K Marriott/night.
"Get your own place"AnywhereAirBNB, VRBO, HomeAwayRenting an apartment can be a great option in Venice especially if your family is large enough that you would otherwise have to get a few hotel rooms. You can find apartments near the Ghetto, and with meals at Chabad, this can definitely be a cheaper option than a hotel.

There are 2 other SPG properties, Hotel Danieli and The Gritti Palace, but there are some downsides to them. Both are SPG Cat. 7 which means you'll be paying a premium to stay there. Danieli is in the Square, but in Dan's TR you'll see that he pointed out there's no manual door, which poses an issue on Shabbos. Dan also writes that Gritti is 10 minutes away from the Square. The Gritti has  undergone extensive renovations and is now fresh and on par with Aman. Many consider it worth it the distance from Chabad. There are very few base rooms, so upgrades are easy to come by.


What to do:

As said a few times so far, the highlight of a trip to Venice is walking the streets/canals and checking out the boundless shops that line the streets. But, there are of course some actual activities that one can do, although it's hard to say that any are "must-do"s.

Attractions & Activities
NameMore InfoComments
________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Doge's PalaceWebsiteYou can get a classic tour of the palace, or you can opt for the Secret Itineraries tour, which will take you down to the dungeons where the prison was and up to the top floors to see offices, a torture chamber, and a court room while listening to the story of Casanova's supposed escape. The Secret Itineraries tour does not cover the main rooms in the palace, but you are free to walk around afterwards on your own.
Jewish Museum/ Ghetto TourWebsiteThe Jewish Museum offers tours of the museum and Ghetto. While the tours of the Ghetto in Rome are highly recommended by DDFers (and many would say a trip to Rome without a tour is nuts), there is not too much talk on DDF about the tours of the Venice Ghetto. Take that as you will. The tour is closer to an hour and costs 10 euro. Without the tour, you can't get in to see the nice Shuls that are not open that season.
Gondola RideN/AYou'll see gondolas everywhere you look. There are a few places where can get one that will take you on a 5 minute ride just going across the width of the canal for a couple of euro (called a "Traghetto"). There are options to get a private, 45-60 minute ride that usually costs around 90 euro. And finally, there's an in between option where you'll be in your own gondola among a group of others that are in their own gondolas. Some companies offer music and a serenade. Do some Googling to see different prices. A gondola ride will give you an additional "real feel" of Venice, but passing on it to save some money isn't a crazy idea. Walking the canals yourself is quite amazing.
San Marco SquareN/AWhether your hotel is in this area or not, this is a nice stop on your walks. A huge, open square with restaurants and shops overlooked by the large church and clock tower. During the day, you'll see people feeding pigeons, and at night, you'll see plenty of street vendors trying to get you to buy a rose for DW or a light up flying saucer. You can go up the bell tower for 8 euro for a beautiful view and you can get the very interesting audio guide for an additional 4 euro.
Lido BeachN/AIf you're in Venice for a few days, perhaps you'll enjoy a quick Vaporetto ride to Lido, where a 10 minute walk will get you onto a free public beach. Warning: Remember that this is a European beach.
Padua                ??                 Synagogue and cemetery dating to the 1500's.

Luxury Launch's Venice Guide nice list of different things to do in Venice


Shuls/Shabbos:

NameMore InfoComments
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Jewish Community of VeniceWebsiteIn the Ghetto, there are 2 community Shuls - one used during the summer and the other during the winter - that are both right next to each other. There are daily Minyanim.
ChabadWebsite


Google Doc to sign up for meals
In the Ghetto, Chabad has their own Shul/Beis Medrash that acts as the Yeshiva for the Chabad students as well as a Shul during daily Minyanim. They also own a storefront that acts as the Chabad house. Chabad owns the fleishig restaurant, Gam Gam, as well as the pizza shop, Gam Gam Goodies, that are described below. On Shabbos, Chabad hosts several meal options. First of all, you could order takeout in advance and pick it up or have it delivered to your hotel. But where's the fun in that? For meals at Chabad, the options have changed as of June 1, 2015:

1) A Meal is offered after Davening both on Friday night and Shabbos day Kiddush - no reservations necessary. This is similar to the previous "free meals" that Chabad used to offer. The meal takes place in the Shul after davening. The meal provides the opportunity to sit at a big meal with Jews from all over the world with all different types of backgrounds, which many found to be an awesome experience. Please note that the "free meals" may be a little more limited in terms of options and quantities of food.

*Pre-reserved meals*
In the old system, there was only 1 way to reserve your own table, but now there are 2 ways. Meals can not be divided between the two locations and are served at any time you want after Davening. Reservations for both options can be made by emailing info@jewishvenice.org and including the calendar date of the Shabbos you will be there and the names/emails of each attendee, as well as choosing one of the below options:

2) Shabbos in the Gallery - This option existed under the old system. Three meals at a private table in a storefront near Gam Gam that normally functions as an art gallery. 90 euro per person

3) Luxury1 Shabbos at Gam Gam Restaurant - Three meals at your private table, with more of a luxury atmosphere & meal, including more food choices, than the Gallery. Minimum donation is 126 euro per person.
Ghimmel GardensWebsite


Food:

NameMore InfoComments
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Gam GamWebsiteA nice fleishig restaurant, owned by the Chabad Rabbi. Some food is better than others, the service is pretty classic, and the prices are a bit above reasonable. But hey, it's Kosher food in Venice! You can eat outside literally at the edge of the canal, which is pretty sweet unless it's cold at night. Reservations are recommended as it can get crowded.
Gam Gam GoodiesN/ALocated just a few steps from Gam Gam, this is a small storefront that serves as a pizza shop (no seating unfortunately, but you can find benches further along in the Ghetto and are welcome to sit in the Chabad house storefront to eat). You might also find other foods like falafel, chocolates, packaged deli and fresh baked goods, which can be great for breakfast (and deli and rolls can be great for a cheaper dinner or to take food with you to your next destination that might not have Kosher food). Pizza is priced fairly and is tasty.
Volpe BakeryWebsiteRight across the alley from Gam Gam Goodies is a bakery serving fresh breads and pastries. According to the link, it's under supervision from the Chief Rabbi of Venice (not the Chabad Rabbi), however, DDFers question the Kashrus here. As of July 2014, the Chazzan at the Italian Shul said he goes into the bakery to light the fire every morning and therefore you can eat there. The place is open on Shabbos, but it must be owned by a non-Jew (or else how could it get a hashgacha?) So, there are some concerns and you may want to check into the Kashrus before you go, but the locals sure make it seem like it's fine.
FrulalaWebsiteFresh fruit smoothies that the locals will tell you are Kosher as long as you get the water-based versions. There are 2 locations - a storefront and a kiosk - that are both on the main walk from San Marco Square to the Ghetto. The drinks are tasty and refreshing, while being reasonably priced. They also offer free shotglass-sized samples, which are a great way to get a quick thirst quencher while walking!
Ghimel GardenTheir FB pageFrom Hershelsdeals Gimmal Garden is a real restaurant, Gam Gam goodies doesn't even have chairs, and is officially a bakery, not a restaurant. so you can't even compare. GamGam goodies opens at 7AM and sells breakfast, Gimmal Garden only opens at 10AM and closes 10PM
Gimmal Garden also offers Shabbos meals, Friday night is meat and Shabbos day is dairy.The food at Gimmal is excellent, they have Pizza, Fish dishes, Pasta, salads, Falafel  ETC....

« Last edited by sam28 on September 12, 2023, 12:02:41 PM »

Author Topic: Venice Master Thread  (Read 909620 times)

Offline shimino1

  • Dansdeals Lifetime Platinum Elite
  • *******
  • Join Date: Apr 2013
  • Posts: 2411
  • Total likes: 133
  • DansDeals.com Hat Tips 10
    • View Profile
  • Location: israel
Re: Venice Master Thread
« Reply #2960 on: November 30, 2017, 05:19:35 PM »
Does anyone have an answer to this question. More specifically if I have a suite for under $200 in the carnival does it make sense to go to Boscolo even if it is nicer?
No

Offline Safetynet

  • Dansdeals Silver Elite
  • **
  • Join Date: Oct 2015
  • Posts: 54
  • Total likes: 3
  • DansDeals.com Hat Tips 0
    • View Profile
  • Location: New york
Re: Venice Master Thread
« Reply #2961 on: December 01, 2017, 10:34:36 AM »
Whats the nicest hotel within a 10-15 minute walking distance to the Kosher restaurants there? Cost doesn't matter.

Offline shimino1

  • Dansdeals Lifetime Platinum Elite
  • *******
  • Join Date: Apr 2013
  • Posts: 2411
  • Total likes: 133
  • DansDeals.com Hat Tips 10
    • View Profile
  • Location: israel
Re: Venice Master Thread
« Reply #2962 on: December 03, 2017, 03:57:01 AM »
Whats the nicest hotel within a 10-15 minute walking distance to the Kosher restaurants there? Cost doesn't matter.
Boscolo

Offline ExGingi

  • Dansdeals Lifetime 10K Presidential Platinum Elite
  • *******
  • Join Date: Nov 2015
  • Posts: 15618
  • Total likes: 7710
  • DansDeals.com Hat Tips 19
    • View Profile
  • Location: 770
  • Programs: בשורת הגאולה. From Exile to Redemption. GIYF. AAdvantage Executive Platinum®
Re: Venice Master Thread
« Reply #2963 on: December 03, 2017, 08:40:32 AM »
Got the following on a whatsapp group on מוצ״ש, might be of interest for anyone planning to stay in Venice for Shabbos.

בשבת האחרונה הוזמנתי להתוועד בוונציה. זו עבודה במשרה מליאה של חזרת שיחה לפני קבלת שבת, נאום בסעודת שבת, והתוועדות עד השעות הקטנות לאחר הסעודה. וחוזר חלילה ביום שבת. שיחה אחרי הקריאה, נאום בסעודה והתוועדות  עד צאת שבת, עם הפסקה  באמצע למנחה.

כנהוג בוונציה, מתרימים את העולים לתורה בלימוד חסידות חב"ד בכלל ותורת הרבי בפרט. כך נתרמים פרקי תניא, מאמרים ושיחות של הרבי וכדו'.

זה מנהג שהשליח, הרב בנין מחזיק בו בעקשנות שנים רבות. הוא ישמח מאוד לקבל תרומות כספיות, שיסייעו בעול הכבד. אבל את ה'מי שברך' הוא מנצל לעידוד לימוד חסידות.

בשבת האחרונה, וישלח, אחד העולים לתורה, חסיד בעלז, התעקש שהוא לא מוכן ללמוד חסידות חב"ד. הוא ילמד בעלז. אבל לא חב"ד. ניסינו לשכנעו בדרכים שונות, קונוונציונאליות, וגם פחות. הובטח לו שכאשר השליח יבקר בבעלז, הוא גם יקבל על עצמו ללמוד חסידות  בעלז... דבר לא עזר!  באיזה שהוא שלב, בחצי צחוק, הצעתי לשליח  שיעבוד עמו כמו אברהם אבינו עם אורחיו, ושיתן לו ברירה בין חסידות לבין תרומה בסכום מפולפל...  הקהל קצת צחק. ההוא כבר הרגיש לא נעים מכל הלחץ,  ובסוף התפשר על ללימוד תניא עם פירוש של איזה רב, מגיד או משהו כזה שלא ממש הכרנו. כנראה מישהו שהוא מרגיש שהוא 'משלו'...

בהתוועדות שלאחרי הסעודה, בעת שהאווירה קצת התחממה, העז אחד האורחים לשאול מה זה ה'ניצול' וה'כפייה' הזו, לנצל אורח שבא להתפלל ללמוד תורת חב"ד דווקא.

ואמרתי לו כך:  כידוע אברהם אבינו היה כופה את אורחיו לברך בשם ה', למה? כיון שהוא העמיד אותם בפני הברירה הפשוטה, אם אתם מסכימים לאמונה שלי שיש ה', והוא ציווה להכניס אורחים, ושזה אפילו יותר חשוב מקבלת פני השכינה, ולכן אני דואג לכם בכזה מקום שומם, הרי טוב, ואם  אתם לא מאמינים בזה, הרי שאני סתם בית מלון באמצע המדבר, אם כן, נא לשלם בהתאם...

ואותו דבר, חשבונו של השליח:
אם אתה מאמין שהרבי הוא הראש של *כל* בני ישראל, ולכן הוא שלח אותי לדאוג *לך* למנין וסעודת שבת, הרי למה שלא תלמד את תורתו?

אבל אם אתה לא מאמין בזה, הרי שאני סתם נמצא כאן על תקן של מלון ושירותי כשרות בחור נדח זה, אם כן, מגיע לי שתשלם לי על כך כדבעי למהוי.
I've been waiting over 5 years with bated breath for someone to say that!
-- Dan

Offline Emkay

  • Dansdeals Lifetime 10K Presidential Platinum Elite
  • *******
  • Join Date: Dec 2012
  • Posts: 14295
  • Total likes: 376
  • DansDeals.com Hat Tips 35
    • View Profile
  • Location: Where I ought to be
Re: Venice Master Thread
« Reply #2964 on: December 03, 2017, 09:22:09 AM »
Got the following on a whatsapp group on מוצ״ש, might be of interest for anyone planning to stay in Venice for Shabbos.

בשבת האחרונה הוזמנתי להתוועד בוונציה. זו עבודה במשרה מליאה של חזרת שיחה לפני קבלת שבת, נאום בסעודת שבת, והתוועדות עד השעות הקטנות לאחר הסעודה. וחוזר חלילה ביום שבת. שיחה אחרי הקריאה, נאום בסעודה והתוועדות  עד צאת שבת, עם הפסקה  באמצע למנחה.

כנהוג בוונציה, מתרימים את העולים לתורה בלימוד חסידות חב"ד בכלל ותורת הרבי בפרט. כך נתרמים פרקי תניא, מאמרים ושיחות של הרבי וכדו'.

זה מנהג שהשליח, הרב בנין מחזיק בו בעקשנות שנים רבות. הוא ישמח מאוד לקבל תרומות כספיות, שיסייעו בעול הכבד. אבל את ה'מי שברך' הוא מנצל לעידוד לימוד חסידות.

בשבת האחרונה, וישלח, אחד העולים לתורה, חסיד בעלז, התעקש שהוא לא מוכן ללמוד חסידות חב"ד. הוא ילמד בעלז. אבל לא חב"ד. ניסינו לשכנעו בדרכים שונות, קונוונציונאליות, וגם פחות. הובטח לו שכאשר השליח יבקר בבעלז, הוא גם יקבל על עצמו ללמוד חסידות  בעלז... דבר לא עזר!  באיזה שהוא שלב, בחצי צחוק, הצעתי לשליח  שיעבוד עמו כמו אברהם אבינו עם אורחיו, ושיתן לו ברירה בין חסידות לבין תרומה בסכום מפולפל...  הקהל קצת צחק. ההוא כבר הרגיש לא נעים מכל הלחץ,  ובסוף התפשר על ללימוד תניא עם פירוש של איזה רב, מגיד או משהו כזה שלא ממש הכרנו. כנראה מישהו שהוא מרגיש שהוא 'משלו'...

בהתוועדות שלאחרי הסעודה, בעת שהאווירה קצת התחממה, העז אחד האורחים לשאול מה זה ה'ניצול' וה'כפייה' הזו, לנצל אורח שבא להתפלל ללמוד תורת חב"ד דווקא.

ואמרתי לו כך:  כידוע אברהם אבינו היה כופה את אורחיו לברך בשם ה', למה? כיון שהוא העמיד אותם בפני הברירה הפשוטה, אם אתם מסכימים לאמונה שלי שיש ה', והוא ציווה להכניס אורחים, ושזה אפילו יותר חשוב מקבלת פני השכינה, ולכן אני דואג לכם בכזה מקום שומם, הרי טוב, ואם  אתם לא מאמינים בזה, הרי שאני סתם בית מלון באמצע המדבר, אם כן, נא לשלם בהתאם...

ואותו דבר, חשבונו של השליח:
אם אתה מאמין שהרבי הוא הראש של *כל* בני ישראל, ולכן הוא שלח אותי לדאוג *לך* למנין וסעודת שבת, הרי למה שלא תלמד את תורתו?

אבל אם אתה לא מאמין בזה, הרי שאני סתם נמצא כאן על תקן של מלון ושירותי כשרות בחור נדח זה, אם כן, מגיע לי שתשלם לי על כך כדבעי למהוי.
For what it's worth I also found it to be a little strange and it left at least one person a week there flustered and uncomfortable.

Offline aygart

  • Dansdeals Lifetime 10K Presidential Platinum Elite
  • *******
  • Join Date: May 2008
  • Posts: 17395
  • Total likes: 14333
  • DansDeals.com Hat Tips 14
    • View Profile
    • Lower Watt Energy Brokers
  • Programs: www.lowerwatt.com
Re: Venice Master Thread
« Reply #2965 on: December 03, 2017, 09:48:08 AM »
Got the following on a whatsapp group on מוצ״ש, might be of interest for anyone planning to stay in Venice for Shabbos.

בשבת האחרונה הוזמנתי להתוועד בוונציה. זו עבודה במשרה מליאה של חזרת שיחה לפני קבלת שבת, נאום בסעודת שבת, והתוועדות עד השעות הקטנות לאחר הסעודה. וחוזר חלילה ביום שבת. שיחה אחרי הקריאה, נאום בסעודה והתוועדות  עד צאת שבת, עם הפסקה  באמצע למנחה.

כנהוג בוונציה, מתרימים את העולים לתורה בלימוד חסידות חב"ד בכלל ותורת הרבי בפרט. כך נתרמים פרקי תניא, מאמרים ושיחות של הרבי וכדו'.

זה מנהג שהשליח, הרב בנין מחזיק בו בעקשנות שנים רבות. הוא ישמח מאוד לקבל תרומות כספיות, שיסייעו בעול הכבד. אבל את ה'מי שברך' הוא מנצל לעידוד לימוד חסידות.

בשבת האחרונה, וישלח, אחד העולים לתורה, חסיד בעלז, התעקש שהוא לא מוכן ללמוד חסידות חב"ד. הוא ילמד בעלז. אבל לא חב"ד. ניסינו לשכנעו בדרכים שונות, קונוונציונאליות, וגם פחות. הובטח לו שכאשר השליח יבקר בבעלז, הוא גם יקבל על עצמו ללמוד חסידות  בעלז... דבר לא עזר!  באיזה שהוא שלב, בחצי צחוק, הצעתי לשליח  שיעבוד עמו כמו אברהם אבינו עם אורחיו, ושיתן לו ברירה בין חסידות לבין תרומה בסכום מפולפל...  הקהל קצת צחק. ההוא כבר הרגיש לא נעים מכל הלחץ,  ובסוף התפשר על ללימוד תניא עם פירוש של איזה רב, מגיד או משהו כזה שלא ממש הכרנו. כנראה מישהו שהוא מרגיש שהוא 'משלו'...

בהתוועדות שלאחרי הסעודה, בעת שהאווירה קצת התחממה, העז אחד האורחים לשאול מה זה ה'ניצול' וה'כפייה' הזו, לנצל אורח שבא להתפלל ללמוד תורת חב"ד דווקא.

ואמרתי לו כך:  כידוע אברהם אבינו היה כופה את אורחיו לברך בשם ה', למה? כיון שהוא העמיד אותם בפני הברירה הפשוטה, אם אתם מסכימים לאמונה שלי שיש ה', והוא ציווה להכניס אורחים, ושזה אפילו יותר חשוב מקבלת פני השכינה, ולכן אני דואג לכם בכזה מקום שומם, הרי טוב, ואם  אתם לא מאמינים בזה, הרי שאני סתם בית מלון באמצע המדבר, אם כן, נא לשלם בהתאם...

ואותו דבר, חשבונו של השליח:
אם אתה מאמין שהרבי הוא הראש של *כל* בני ישראל, ולכן הוא שלח אותי לדאוג *לך* למנין וסעודת שבת, הרי למה שלא תלמד את תורתו?

אבל אם אתה לא מאמין בזה, הרי שאני סתם נמצא כאן על תקן של מלון ושירותי כשרות בחור נדח זה, אם כן, מגיע לי שתשלם לי על כך כדבעי למהוי.
The analogy reeks
Feelings don't care about your facts

Offline jose34

  • Dansdeals Lifetime Platinum Elite
  • *******
  • Join Date: Aug 2016
  • Posts: 2396
  • Total likes: 154
  • DansDeals.com Hat Tips 2
    • View Profile
Re: Venice Master Thread
« Reply #2966 on: December 03, 2017, 01:51:02 PM »
Got the following on a whatsapp group on מוצ״ש, might be of interest for anyone planning to stay in Venice for Shabbos.

בשבת האחרונה הוזמנתי להתוועד בוונציה. זו עבודה במשרה מליאה של חזרת שיחה לפני קבלת שבת, נאום בסעודת שבת, והתוועדות עד השעות הקטנות לאחר הסעודה. וחוזר חלילה ביום שבת. שיחה אחרי הקריאה, נאום בסעודה והתוועדות  עד צאת שבת, עם הפסקה  באמצע למנחה.

כנהוג בוונציה, מתרימים את העולים לתורה בלימוד חסידות חב"ד בכלל ותורת הרבי בפרט. כך נתרמים פרקי תניא, מאמרים ושיחות של הרבי וכדו'.

זה מנהג שהשליח, הרב בנין מחזיק בו בעקשנות שנים רבות. הוא ישמח מאוד לקבל תרומות כספיות, שיסייעו בעול הכבד. אבל את ה'מי שברך' הוא מנצל לעידוד לימוד חסידות.

בשבת האחרונה, וישלח, אחד העולים לתורה, חסיד בעלז, התעקש שהוא לא מוכן ללמוד חסידות חב"ד. הוא ילמד בעלז. אבל לא חב"ד. ניסינו לשכנעו בדרכים שונות, קונוונציונאליות, וגם פחות. הובטח לו שכאשר השליח יבקר בבעלז, הוא גם יקבל על עצמו ללמוד חסידות  בעלז... דבר לא עזר!  באיזה שהוא שלב, בחצי צחוק, הצעתי לשליח  שיעבוד עמו כמו אברהם אבינו עם אורחיו, ושיתן לו ברירה בין חסידות לבין תרומה בסכום מפולפל...  הקהל קצת צחק. ההוא כבר הרגיש לא נעים מכל הלחץ,  ובסוף התפשר על ללימוד תניא עם פירוש של איזה רב, מגיד או משהו כזה שלא ממש הכרנו. כנראה מישהו שהוא מרגיש שהוא 'משלו'...

בהתוועדות שלאחרי הסעודה, בעת שהאווירה קצת התחממה, העז אחד האורחים לשאול מה זה ה'ניצול' וה'כפייה' הזו, לנצל אורח שבא להתפלל ללמוד תורת חב"ד דווקא.

ואמרתי לו כך:  כידוע אברהם אבינו היה כופה את אורחיו לברך בשם ה', למה? כיון שהוא העמיד אותם בפני הברירה הפשוטה, אם אתם מסכימים לאמונה שלי שיש ה', והוא ציווה להכניס אורחים, ושזה אפילו יותר חשוב מקבלת פני השכינה, ולכן אני דואג לכם בכזה מקום שומם, הרי טוב, ואם  אתם לא מאמינים בזה, הרי שאני סתם בית מלון באמצע המדבר, אם כן, נא לשלם בהתאם...

ואותו דבר, חשבונו של השליח:
אם אתה מאמין שהרבי הוא הראש של *כל* בני ישראל, ולכן הוא שלח אותי לדאוג *לך* למנין וסעודת שבת, הרי למה שלא תלמד את תורתו?

אבל אם אתה לא מאמין בזה, הרי שאני סתם נמצא כאן על תקן של מלון ושירותי כשרות בחור נדח זה, אם כן, מגיע לי שתשלם לי על כך כדבעי למהוי.

Anyone want to translate to English. I'm too lazy to break my teeth over the hebrew.  ::)

Offline Emkay

  • Dansdeals Lifetime 10K Presidential Platinum Elite
  • *******
  • Join Date: Dec 2012
  • Posts: 14295
  • Total likes: 376
  • DansDeals.com Hat Tips 35
    • View Profile
  • Location: Where I ought to be
Re: Venice Master Thread
« Reply #2967 on: December 03, 2017, 02:32:04 PM »
Anyone want to translate to English. I'm too lazy to break my teeth over the hebrew.  ::)
Instead of giving money for a mi shebeirach in Chabad of VCE they make you commit to learn a certain amount of chapters of Tanya. One belzer chasid didn't like that and put up a fight, and chabad tried somehow equating his point of view to Abraham and said that if you believe that the Rebbe is the Rebbe of all jews then why wouldn't you want to learn his Torah.
Or something like that.

Offline ExGingi

  • Dansdeals Lifetime 10K Presidential Platinum Elite
  • *******
  • Join Date: Nov 2015
  • Posts: 15618
  • Total likes: 7710
  • DansDeals.com Hat Tips 19
    • View Profile
  • Location: 770
  • Programs: בשורת הגאולה. From Exile to Redemption. GIYF. AAdvantage Executive Platinum®
Re: Venice Master Thread
« Reply #2968 on: December 03, 2017, 04:10:41 PM »
Instead of giving money for a mi shebeirach in Chabad of VCE they make you commit to learn a certain amount of chapters of Tanya. One belzer chasid didn't like that and put up a fight, and chabad the writer of the whatsapp post, who filled in for the Shliach this past Shabbos tried somehow equating his point of view to Abraham and said that if you believe that the Rebbe is the Rebbe of all jews then why wouldn't you want to learn his Torah.
Or something like that.

For what it's worth I also found it to be a little strange and it left at least one person a week there flustered and uncomfortable.
Nothing wrong with feeling uncomfortable, if that's what gets people to do the right thing. That is one way of motivating action.

FWIW, I've never been to Chabad of Venice, nor have I heard about the local practice up until yesterday. I have definitely seen it done elsewhere, where people were asked to commit a certain quota of learning as "payment" for an aliya. While some (or many) might find it "strange", if you think about it, it seems like a very noble idea. Asking a person to commit to do another mitzvah, in exchange for being honored with a mitzvah.

The analogy reeks
Not sure which detail of the analogy reeks in your mind, but one thing needs to be set straight:

Chabad Houses were not established as a service for Jewish travelers seeking a Minyan and Kosher Food! They were established in order to bring Yiddishkeit to all corners of the globe, and in order to make Yiddishkeit accessible to every Yid.

I actually find the fact that a frum person allows himself to benefit from the existence a Chabad house that enables him to daven with a minyan and have kosher food, yet would so vehemently (based on the description in the post, I definitely wasn't there) oppose learning some additional Torah, even if it is not something he would usually learn, reeks much more than any analogy that might have been made to אאע"ה's practices.

The analogy actually seems to spell out what seems to be "hiding" between the lines. Why in the world would a Yid refuse to learn Torah? Is it possible that it might only be because he has something against Lubavitch? If that is the case, if indeed the person is opposed to Lubavitch, then he should be paying the FMV of bringing a minyan and a Sefer Torah, along with abundant kosher food, to a place where he wants to spend Shabbos.
I've been waiting over 5 years with bated breath for someone to say that!
-- Dan

Offline aygart

  • Dansdeals Lifetime 10K Presidential Platinum Elite
  • *******
  • Join Date: May 2008
  • Posts: 17395
  • Total likes: 14333
  • DansDeals.com Hat Tips 14
    • View Profile
    • Lower Watt Energy Brokers
  • Programs: www.lowerwatt.com
Re: Venice Master Thread
« Reply #2969 on: December 03, 2017, 04:27:22 PM »
How does the philosophy of bringing yiddishkeit to all corners of the globe mean that הוא הראש של *כל* בני ישראל that one should be obligated to learn his teachings?
I agree that it was out of place for him to refuse.
Feelings don't care about your facts

Offline jose34

  • Dansdeals Lifetime Platinum Elite
  • *******
  • Join Date: Aug 2016
  • Posts: 2396
  • Total likes: 154
  • DansDeals.com Hat Tips 2
    • View Profile
Re: Venice Master Thread
« Reply #2970 on: December 03, 2017, 04:45:57 PM »
Instead of giving money for a mi shebeirach in Chabad of VCE they make you commit to learn a certain amount of chapters of Tanya. One belzer chasid didn't like that and put up a fight, and chabad tried somehow equating his point of view to Abraham and said that if you believe that the Rebbe is the Rebbe of all jews then why wouldn't you want to learn his Torah.
Or something like that.

Thanks for translation! When I was there I had that! Ok who cares! If you dont like it, dont get an aliyah. The way I look at it is that they are there to do their thing- whatever that maybe be. And most people are there to  have a nice vacation and enjoy minyanim and kosher food courtesy of Chabad.

Offline ExGingi

  • Dansdeals Lifetime 10K Presidential Platinum Elite
  • *******
  • Join Date: Nov 2015
  • Posts: 15618
  • Total likes: 7710
  • DansDeals.com Hat Tips 19
    • View Profile
  • Location: 770
  • Programs: בשורת הגאולה. From Exile to Redemption. GIYF. AAdvantage Executive Platinum®
Re: Venice Master Thread
« Reply #2971 on: December 03, 2017, 04:46:25 PM »
How does the philosophy of bringing yiddishkeit to all corners of the globe mean that הוא הראש של *כל* בני ישראל that one should be obligated to learn his teachings?
I agree that it was out of place for him to refuse.
As I said, I didn't write the post, I just copied and pasted something I received. If I were to write it, I might have written it differently.

If I understood the writer correctly, I think he is implying what I wrote
Quote
The analogy actually seems to spell out what seems to be "hiding" between the lines. Why in the world would a Yid refuse to learn Torah? Is it possible that it might only be because he has something against Lubavitch? If that is the case, if indeed the person is opposed to Lubavitch, then he should be paying the FMV of bringing a minyan and a Sefer Torah, along with abundant kosher food, to a place where he wants to spend Shabbos.

It's probably not so much that if he is ראש כל בני ישראל one should be obligated to learn his teachings, but probably the other way around, that if you won't recognize him for what he is, to the extent that you refuse to learn his Torah (because....) then...
I've been waiting over 5 years with bated breath for someone to say that!
-- Dan

Offline aygart

  • Dansdeals Lifetime 10K Presidential Platinum Elite
  • *******
  • Join Date: May 2008
  • Posts: 17395
  • Total likes: 14333
  • DansDeals.com Hat Tips 14
    • View Profile
    • Lower Watt Energy Brokers
  • Programs: www.lowerwatt.com
Re: Venice Master Thread
« Reply #2972 on: December 03, 2017, 05:30:08 PM »
As I said, I didn't write the post, I just copied and pasted something I received. If I were to write it, I might have written it differently.

If I understood the writer correctly, I think he is implying what I wrote
It's probably not so much that if he is ראש כל בני ישראל one should be obligated to learn his teachings, but probably the other way around, that if you won't recognize him for what he is, to the extent that you refuse to learn his Torah (because....) then...
Much better
Feelings don't care about your facts

Offline Safetynet

  • Dansdeals Silver Elite
  • **
  • Join Date: Oct 2015
  • Posts: 54
  • Total likes: 3
  • DansDeals.com Hat Tips 0
    • View Profile
  • Location: New york
Re: Venice Master Thread
« Reply #2973 on: December 05, 2017, 02:33:26 PM »
Boscolo

Is there any other hotels in that category?

Offline mimb

  • Dansdeals Platinum Elite + Lifetime Gold Elite
  • ******
  • Join Date: Mar 2015
  • Posts: 870
  • Total likes: 63
  • DansDeals.com Hat Tips 3
    • View Profile
  • Programs: AA, United, Delta, AMEX, CHASE UR, SPG
Re: Venice Master Thread
« Reply #2974 on: December 28, 2017, 01:24:57 PM »
Is the Boscolo Venezia the best points option now due to the 1-3 SPG to marriott points? Seems like it would price out at 15k SPG points per night now.

Offline ludmila

  • Dansdeals Lifetime Presidential Platinum Elite
  • *********
  • Join Date: Aug 2012
  • Posts: 5147
  • Total likes: 271
  • DansDeals.com Hat Tips 0
    • View Profile
  • Location: IND
  • Programs: Hilton Diamond,Marriott Platinum,SPG Platinum.
Re: Venice Master Thread
« Reply #2975 on: December 28, 2017, 10:36:28 PM »
Is the Boscolo Venezia the best points option now due to the 1-3 SPG to marriott points? Seems like it would price out at 15k SPG points per night now.
Not sure if it is the best point option, i'll check what else is available on points, but it is a good deal for Venice.
I was the Best,still the Best, and will always be the Best.
Pele Good,Maradona Better, George Best.

Offline mimb

  • Dansdeals Platinum Elite + Lifetime Gold Elite
  • ******
  • Join Date: Mar 2015
  • Posts: 870
  • Total likes: 63
  • DansDeals.com Hat Tips 3
    • View Profile
  • Programs: AA, United, Delta, AMEX, CHASE UR, SPG
Re: Venice Master Thread
« Reply #2976 on: December 29, 2017, 09:14:47 AM »
Not sure if it is the best point option, i'll check what else is available on points, but it is a good deal for Venice.

Compared to the westin it seems like a no-brainer. Not the best points/cash rate but figure I can splurge a little  ;D

Offline SrulyP

  • Dansdeals Platinum Elite + Lifetime Silver Elite
  • *****
  • Join Date: Jul 2013
  • Posts: 665
  • Total likes: 7
  • DansDeals.com Hat Tips 0
    • View Profile
  • Programs: SPG Gold; Hyatt Platinum; National Emerald EE; Hertz five star; Avis Five Star
Re: Venice Master Thread
« Reply #2977 on: January 02, 2018, 08:19:36 PM »
I plan on being in venice for two days in the summer (august). Anyone have personal experience about hotels, I am trying to figure out which of the three I should go to:
Carnival Place
Westin Europa
Boscolo Venezia,

Boscolo looks pretty run down in the pictures so that seems like a 3rd choice. Westin looks nicer but I have seen positive reviews of Carnival. If the price is the same, which should I choose?

Offline nescafe

  • Dansdeals Platinum Elite + Lifetime Silver Elite
  • *****
  • Join Date: Jun 2016
  • Posts: 748
  • Total likes: 37
  • DansDeals.com Hat Tips 2
    • View Profile
  • Location: Brooklyn
Re: Venice Master Thread
« Reply #2978 on: January 02, 2018, 11:44:14 PM »
I plan on being in venice for two days in the summer (august). Anyone have personal experience about hotels, I am trying to figure out which of the three I should go to:
Carnival Place
Westin Europa
Boscolo Venezia,

Boscolo looks pretty run down in the pictures so that seems like a 3rd choice. Westin looks nicer but I have seen positive reviews of Carnival. If the price is the same, which should I choose?

We stayed in Carnival Palace & were very satisfied with the room, service, & location

Offline Dan

  • Administrator
  • Dansdeals Lifetime 50K Diamond Elite
  • **********
  • Join Date: May 2008
  • Posts: 67598
  • Total likes: 16909
  • DansDeals.com Hat Tips 16442
  • Gender: Male
    • View Profile
  • Location: CLE
  • Programs: UA GS, AA EXP, DL Dirt, Hyatt Glob, Fairmont Lifetime Plat, DD Diamond, Blocked By @NeriaKraus
Re: Venice Master Thread
« Reply #2979 on: January 02, 2018, 11:45:39 PM »
Loved the Westin.
Wouldn't do it with young kids though.
Save your time, I don't answer PM. Post it in the forum and a dedicated DDF'er will get back to you as soon as possible.