One day or two

[Proisrael]

Just curious how many people are on during second day

[Dan]

"איין טאג"
-Rav Farkash

[farmbochur]

"איין טאג"
-Rav Farkash

Can I get a HT?

[MeirS]

"איין טאג"
-Rav Farkash

Obviously, without explaining some of the details of the situation, no one can compare one case to another.
(Although, I'll assume you're talking about your current situation.)
When I was in Israel my Rov told me to keep 2 days.

[Dan]

Obviously, without explaining some of the details of the situation, no one can compare one case to another.
(Although, I'll assume you're talking about your current situation.)
When I was in Israel my Rov told me to keep 2 days.

I sure hope nobody is taking halachic advice from a forum post.

[aygart]

I sure hope nobody is taking halachic advice from a forum post.

+1

[ExGingi]

"איין טאג"
-Rav Farkash

Isn't it beautiful that one can pick which Rov to ask in order to get the answer one wants to get.

My son, I guess taking after his father, chose to spend Shavuos in Tzfas where he could spend 2 days Yom Tov without being the only one doing so. (Though several years ago I must have been the only person keeping 2nd day where I was stuck for Shavuos).

[Dan]

Isn't it beautiful that one can pick which Rov to ask in order to get the answer one wants to get.

My Rov told me who to call, but thanks for playing.
I had gotten the same psak from Rav Ashkenazi in the past.

[davidrotts63]

My Rov told me who to call, but thanks for playing.
I had gotten the same psak from Rav Ashkenazi in the past.

Can we get the explanation for the Psak?

[ExGingi]

My Rov told me who to call.

Exactly.

[ExGingi]

My Rov told me who to call, but thanks for playing.
I had gotten the same psak from Rav Ashkenazi in the past.

But if you would have preferred to get a psak to keep two days, you might have been told to call Rav Landa (the son, in Tzfas). Though I am not sure what he would say to someone in your situation who is traveling with the entire family.

[Dr Moose]

Can we get the explanation for the Psak?

I believe Chabad holds you go based on current location.

[Dan]

I believe Chabad holds you go based on current location.

Aka, how it was in the good old days of Aliyah l'regel.
There are exceptions, but that's the general consensus.

[davidrotts63]

Aka, how it was in the good old days of Aliyah l'regel.
There are exceptions, but that's the general consensus.

Interesting. So why wouldn't you hold 1 day?

[Dan]

Interesting. So why wouldn't you hold 1 day?

Ask @ExGingi

[ExGingi]

Ask @ExGingi

I am no Rov or Posek. But I would do anything possible in order to have as much Yom Tov as possible. I really feel bad for people that have abbreviated Yomim Toivim.

[DrDanny]

I am no Rov or Posek. But I would do anything possible in order to have as much Yom Tov as possible. I really feel bad for people that have abbreviated Yomim Toivim.

Just something to keep in mind.
YT = Derabanan
Tefillan = Deoraissa

[ExGingi]

Aka, how it was in the good old days of Aliyah l'regel.

See footnote 74) (right after footnote 73. For some technical reason seems like there's a misalignment that has 2 footnotes numbered 74).

https://www.chabad.org/therebbe/article_cdo/aid/3140662/jewish/-.htm


Source of that footnote: http://hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=49984&st=&pgnum=252&hilite=

[Dan]

I am no Rov or Posek. But I would do anything possible in order to have as much Yom Tov as possible. I really feel bad for people that have abbreviated Yomim Toivim.

What does your feeling have to do with Shulchan Aruch Harav?

Don't go to EY for YT if you want, but why shop around for a minority Chabad opinion?

[ExGingi]

What does your feeling have to do with Shulchan Aruch Harav?

Don't go to EY for YT if you want, but why shop around for a minority Chabad opinion?

https://www.chabad.org/therebbe/livingtorah/player_cdo/aid/3226536/jewish/Thought-for-the-Day.htm

2:02