Preshburger Rov escaped the Nazis and wasn't in Auschwitz, the amazing story was likely with another גוטער איד.I thought something did not make sense in the story, thanks for clarifying There is a fascinating ישמח משה explaining why a צדיק is allowed to be moser nefesh for other than the ג׳ חמורות too;
A better question would be machine matzo vs. CS
Do the machmirim eat machine matza שעבר עליו פסח?
Also is CS a חשש דאורייתא?
Does anyone that won't use processed products on Pesach, then use then on the 8th day? Would seem to be the same logic as gebroktz?
AP dead or Obi dead?
There are communities where they are meikil in general on acharon shel Pesach (such as regarding mishing) however in the sicha about gebrokst the Rebbe says that the only area the Rabbeim changed from the rest of Yom tov is gebrokst.
And not as a Kula! But rather were mehader to eat matzo with EVERYTHING.
in that case its a chumra dasa lidei kula.
What's the reason ע"פ הלכה to be lenient on Acharon about something that's a חשש דאורייתא?
To show it isn’t אסור according to the strict letter of the law and is only a stringency. The last day is certainly only מדרבנן so stringencies aren’t as crucial.
Does the same logic apply to all Chumras on second days (of other Yom tovs too)? They should be allowed since it's only מדרבנן?
Technically speaking yes. So for example many will end YT at a earlier time for the second day. I presume it became more of a “thing” by pesach because of the food angle, which the שולחן ערוך הרב invokes עונג יום טוב for.
I believe it is explained as a way of showing that those who do "less" than you are not doing anything wrong. That is especially relevant on Pesach where there are so many disparate minhagim.
Also pesach has much more chumros that are really only a חשש בעלמא which is due to extra stringencies in regards to chametz.
Nice pshat but doesn’t sound like it from the מהרי״ל which is the source of the רמ״א in תס״ז.
He gave the famous pshat al pi chasidus and he's actually right, the זרע קודש actually says that.
What's the reason ע"פ הלכה[/i]
actually right