i didnt say it isnt all im asking is who said its good? i didnt even know he was the one who did it, where did u get that from?
Paging @Tim T we went through this once and found documentation of her Geirus which was done by R Herschel Shacter, Chatzhel Lookstien (who holds you don't need kabulas mitzvos) and a chasidshe rav from monsey but don't recall his name of hand. Either way it was definitely a good Geirus...
Besides that if she got a heter that's it Noone is forcing you to accept her Ravs psak and any speculation of her not really getting one etc is regular lashon hara/motsie shem ra... even if you think she's a mumar...
It's a whole different discussion of what the psak is based on... and you deff don't know the security situation to speculate what they could have or couldn't have done...