Ask a Lubavitcher Anything

[koplonko]

Why do my thoughts matter?

Probably most frequent quote from you over here is "what's a lubavitcher"

[koplonko]

This concept would dictate what, in our specific discussion?

That since the Rebbe learns (that according to the alter rebbe) one could eat chometz and say yale veyovo, some chassidim will purposely do it

[imayid2]

That since the Rebbe learns (that according to the alter rebbe) one could eat chometz and say yale veyovo, some chassidim will purposely do it

Why wouldn’t you have לאידך גיסא, that since the Rebbe said he wouldn’t do it because he didn’t see the hanhaga, chassidim should purposely not do it?

[jj1000]

Why wouldn’t you have לאידך גיסא, that since the Rebbe said he wouldn’t do it because he didn’t see the hanhaga, chassidim should purposely not do it?

Same reason Rabbi Tarfon would have deserved to be attacked by bandits while saying Shema.

Doing what everyone does, doesn't prove anything.

[koplonko]

Why wouldn’t you have לאידך גיסא, that since the Rebbe said he wouldn’t do it because he didn’t see the hanhaga, chassidim should purposely not do it?

There are chassidim that take your view.
The counter argument is that רב כהנא also didn't use such a הדס, but since he held its kosher therefore רב אחא specifically used it.
Like I said:

A major sugya in chabad

[Dan]

Seems like the party line is that we don't do it.

[EliJelly]

Seems like the party line is that we don't do it.

So from where did you pick it up, on your own from that sicha?

[Dan]

So from where did you pick it up, on your own from that sicha?

From the Cliff Notes for Likutei Sichos, which are pretty great when you need to give 7 speeches in 10 days.

[koplonko]

Seems like the party line is that we don't do it.

where did you pick it up

Who is "we"?

[Dan]

Who is "we"?

Go ask the translator.

[koplonko]

Go ask the translator.

Now I see in the footnote. A bit surprising, if I see R' Avtzon I'll ask him if he knows whose idea it is

[gozalim]

It's hardly obvious that כיון דנפיק trumps ללכת בדרכיו (or whatever term you want to use for that), much less when accompanied by expressed hesitation.

Most of the times the rebbe used כיון דנפיק (here he did not), it coincided with, not countered, הנהגת רבו"נ

In general, (ניט) געזען ביי'ם שווער was bordering on hora'a

(not to mention what @koplonko mentioned in the TR thread...)