Which hagagdah do you use? (to prepare for/lead the seder) + Share a DT

[yungermanchik]

I don't understand the question

If there was no Mashchis (i.e. Saraf), why would you need a siman for the Mashchis?

(famous question, dealt with at length in the Maaseh Hashem, Masseh Nissim among others)

[yfr bachur]

I don't understand the question

I think it maybe based on a missunderstanding.
AFAIK, it didnt help any egyptian first born to go hide in the marked house of a jew, i.e. hashem didnt passover the houses bec they were marked he apssed over they jews bec they kept the mitzvos and had zchusim and wernt metzriem.

[EliJelly]

I don't understand the question

אני ולא מלאך אני ולא שליח וכו׳ is contradicted by לא יתן המשחית לבא אל בתיכם לנגף.

[EliJelly]

If there was no Mashchis (i.e. Saraf), why would you need a siman for the Mashchis?

(famous question, dealt with at length in the Maaseh Hashem, Masseh Nissim among others)

IIRC there is a very famous רעק״א said over by many Pidyon Habens dealing with this. @imayid2 can you locate it please?

[Definitions2]

אני ולא מלאך אני ולא שליח וכו׳ is contradicted by לא יתן המשחית לבא אל בתיכם לנגף.

Ahh you're saying the mashchis is a type of Malach?
I didn't understand it to mean that.

If there was no Mashchis (i.e. Saraf), why would you need a siman for the Mashchis?

(famous question, dealt with at length in the Maaseh Hashem, Masseh Nissim among others)

Not sure what you mean. I always heard like yfr said that it's for a zchus

[EliJelly]

Ahh you're saying the mashchis is a type of Malach?

Yes, as indicated by שכיון שניתנה רשות למשחית אינו מבחין

[imayid2]

IIRC there is a very famous רעק״א said over by many Pidyon Habens dealing with this. @imayid2 can you locate it please?

[EliJelly]

Never disappoints!!

[yoohoo]

What’s the answer

[imayid2]

On a related note I never quite understood the ליל שימורים related protections we find in regard to ליל פסח. After all by ליל שימורים of mitzrayim itself there was sakana as it says ואיש לא תצא מפתח ביתו עד בוקר.

[notyettaken]

https://judaicaplaza.com/products/f-600-5?variant=32551770062945
Great pictures and very engaging. There is explanation in back for sources on all the pictures.

[yoohoo]

If anyone has cute ideas/short vorts for young kids please share. Tia

[YitzyS]

https://judaicaplaza.com/products/f-600-5?variant=32551770062945
Great pictures and very engaging. There is explanation in back for sources on all the pictures.

I bought this for my wife a few years back, and she loves it.

[jackofall]

See The Niseevos's hagadah that says just the opposite, based on the Zohar (Pesach al shem mah). Extra shmira is needed precisely because the makah was done by HKB"H.

[Definitions2]

Zecher lmikdash khillel... You might say that you see from here that matzah was soft and flexible. But not necessarily. It could be the meat was the wrap.

My own 2 cents.

[cmey]

Zecher lmikdash khillel... You might say that you see from here that matzah was soft and flexible. But not necessarily. It could be the meat was the wrap.

My own 2 cents.

We know it from other places like the Gemara where chametz and matza loaves are mixed up and you can’t tell which is chametz and which is matza

[dealfinder11]

Zecher lmikdash khillel... You might say that you see from here that matzah was soft and flexible. But not necessarily. It could be the meat was the wrap.

My own 2 cents.

Yeah it was basically a lamb shwarma im chassa vketzat charif.

[mevinyavin]

Yeah it was basically a lamb shwarma im chassa vketzat charif.

Lechora without the ketzat charif. If chasa was the ideal maror used, why would they put in horseradish? But I laughed out loud.

[Definitions2]

I just realized this year. It says hashata hacha lshana haba...
But usually it's pronounced hashta not hashata. IDK what's different in dikduk

[aygart]

I just realized this year. It says hashata hacha lshana haba...
But usually it's pronounced hashta not hashata. IDK what's different in dikduk

Hashta means now HaShata means this year.