I have nothing on my license and my rate kept going up even as I passed the supposed magical age of 25.
Try a new quote with them online without giving your social. Sometimes they price it cheaper for new customers. Then you'll just have to explain to the agent that you already have a policy, and they can adjust your current one.
Also if you take a defensive driving course (even online) they're required to knock off 10% from your liability (in NY).