I ended up getting 2 bottles:
The new Oban: Oban little bay which cost about $65.
Auchnagie, from the lost distillery. They mixed single malts to create the flavor of the original distillery that closed in 1911 and is supposed to be very smooth and good. They have 3 from the lost distillery: Auchnagie,gerston and Stratheden. I believe the stratheden is smokey and the other 2 smooth.
The cost of the Auchnagie was $60.