OK, removed.
There's no question (in my mind at least) he fits the criteria to be on this list
Will certain hotels/resorts/restaurants or any other facilities or practitioners be asked first if they grant permission to be discussed/rated/reviewed or listed on a DDF or any other forum?! This just sounds absurd IMHO.
The rumor was that he was getting a minyan, while the official Chabad in Maui wasn't.
This list is meant to be a resource for travelers, why on Earth would one want to exclude such valuable information?!
This is not a "blacklist" even if certain people may perceive it as such.
This list isn't meant to be a philosophical discussion or to be putting a label on anyone. If I were visiting Maui I'd want to know about this place.
...Just my 2 cents.