I've only gotten credit for 1/4 cards. I sent an SM to amex and mentioned that one of the cards that I'm waiting on is Citi AAdvantage. I got this in response: "I'd like to inform you that the Citi AAdvantage Card is a third party issued Card and it is not eligible for the $25.00 credit." So I replied, "why was I able to register it and got a confirmation email from American Express that my purchase on Small Business Saturday went through?" To which amex replied, "I'd like to inform you that this Card is issued and serviced by Citi Bank. The American Express Blue Box on the Card signifies the Card is accepted at all American Express Merchant locations. However, for security and confidentiality, we do not have access to your account. Therefore, I request you contact them Toll-Free 866-490-2484 24 hours, 7 days a week. You'll get the exact confirmation and information about the credit."
Uh thanks! I called citi (by accident!) last week and they had no idea what Small Business Saturday was!!! I doubt they'll be able to help with my credit.
I will wait it out a little longer to see if the credit magically appears.