Chabad Minhagim: Pros & Cons

[Yehuda57]

When did singing Adon Olam after davening on shabbos start?

Whenever it starts, it takes forever to finish.

[ckmk47]

Where exactly is tehillim said, and how many/which kapitlach?

The tehillim is divided into 5 'sefarim'.  Also into 7 'yoms' corresponding to days of the week.  Also 30 'yoms' corresponding to days of the month.
Most tehillims have these divisions notated.


Lubavitchers each day say the perakim designated for the yom of the month.  Along with Chumash ( one aliya's worth  each day), and Tanya (entire Tanya finished each year).
Sefer Chitas - chumash, tehillim, tanya

[churnbabychurn]

Those are not more recent?

How is their saying tehilim after any different than when they do that in BMG?

You obviously don't know much about this topic.

[churnbabychurn]

When did singing Adon Olam after davening on shabbos start?

Never seen it done

[ExGingi]

You obviously don't know much about this topic.

You seem to hint that you are extremely knowledgeable. Why don't you enlighten everyone?

[churnbabychurn]

Sinas chinam?

-1

[ExGingi]

Never seen it done

I guess you live in one of these.

[churnbabychurn]

Who changed nussach hatefila?

Fwiu often shiur starts right after davening, whether it's a short halacha, mishayis, or a sif chofetz chaim, isn't that terrible as well? To change davening like that?

This reminds me of the gadol that said at least they are adding rosh hashanas not taking away.
--------------------

You need a serious serious Chesbon nefesh this Y"K, if you get disturbed by other jews saying more tehillim. There is clearly something wrong with your outlook on Judaism and life in general.

The issue is precisely the fact that chabbad tried/did institute this as a fundamental part of Seder tefilas shachris.

It has nothing to do with sinas chinam, or anything against anyone saying Tehilim all day long.
It is about having the authority to change Seder hatefila.

This is a sacred thing that shouldn't be adjusted on a whim. It is not just done in modern times.

I've said enough to present the opposing views... Still love y'all.

[ExGingi]

The issue is precisely the fact that chabbad tried/did institute this as a fundamental part of Seder tefilas shachris.


It has nothing to do with sinas chinam, or anything against anyone saying Tehilim all day long.
It is about having the authority to change Seder hatefila.

Yet the sources that I brought clearly state אחר התפילה

This is a sacred thing that shouldn't be adjusted on a whim. It is not just done in modern times.

You don't seem to have a clear definition or understanding of what is sacred (or you wouldn't refer to a תקנה of a Tzaddik the way you just did). You are also seemingly unable to substantiate and back up any of your statements or claims.

I've said enough to present the opposing views... Still love y'all.

Sound a little like the guy described here.

[aygart]

You obviously don't know much about this topic.

Maybe. What am I missing?

[Yehuda57]

The issue is precisely the fact that chabbad tried/did institute this as a fundamental part of Seder tefilas shachris.

It has nothing to do with sinas chinam, or anything against anyone saying Tehilim all day long.
It is about having the authority to change Seder hatefila.

This is a sacred thing that shouldn't be adjusted on a whim. It is not just done in modern times.

I've said enough to present the opposing views... Still love y'all.

As someone who doesn't use foul language in real life, you have a distinct ability to get me to wish to curse rabidly and angrily online.

[Yehuda57]

Never seen it done

It's done in thousands of shuls around the world.
But please, tell us more about your expertise in modern day nusach hatefillah.

[churnbabychurn]

It's done in thousands of shuls around the world.
But please, tell us more about your expertise in modern day nusach hatefillah.

And it's a new thing?

[Yehuda57]

And it's a new thing?

I don't know, but I would guess it is not as new as Tehillim. But you'll never guess what it *does* have in common with the minhag of "תהלים נאכן דאווענען". (hint: its right there in the name of the Chabad custom.)

[koplonko]

רחמני ליצלן!!!!!

https://www.jdn.co.il/קהילות/179018
Look what a modern goyishe thisng he did after davening (mincha)!! He said tehilim rachmono litzlan!!
I hope yom Kippur is mechaper.....

[jj1000]

The issue is precisely the fact that chabbad tried/did institute this as a fundamental part of Seder tefilas shachris.

It has nothing to do with sinas chinam, or anything against anyone saying Tehilim all day long.
It is about having the authority to change Seder hatefila.

This is a sacred thing that shouldn't be adjusted on a whim. It is not just done in modern times.

I've said enough to present the opposing views... Still love y'all.

BUT WAIT!

It gets WORSE!

Chabad GIVES TZEDAKA BEFORE DAVENING! OY GEVALT!

THE GOYIM!!!!

You need a serious serious Chesbon nefesh this Y"K, if you get disturbed by other jews saying more tehillim. There is clearly something wrong with your outlook on Judaism and life in general. When someone is doing a good thing and you have a problem with it, you really need to reexamine your outlook.

[churnbabychurn]

BUT WAIT!

It gets WORSE!

Chabad GIVES TZEDAKA BEFORE DAVENING! OY GEVALT!

THE GOYIM!!!!

You need a serious serious Chesbon nefesh this Y"K, if you get disturbed by other jews saying more tehillim. There is clearly something wrong with your outlook on Judaism and life in general. When someone is doing a good thing and you have a problem with it, you really need to reexamine your outlook.

Ok. Thanks I will take your suggestions under consideration.

But for the record, I don't have a problem with Jews saying Tehilim,giving tzedaka or even learning rambam for that matter.

[ExGingi]

But for the record, I don't have a problem with Jews saying Tehilim,giving tzedaka or even learning rambam for that matter.

I never thought you did, nor did I get that impression from your posts above. Unfortunately the impression that came across was of you having a problem with a תקנה or הוספה בקודש instituted by certain tzaddikim (do you have a problem with daf hayomi?).

I hope this is all a misunderstanding, but you should be aware of the way it comes across.

גמר חתימה טובה.

[jj1000]

Ok. Thanks I will take your suggestions under consideration.

But for the record, I don't have a problem with Jews saying Tehilim,giving tzedaka or even learning rambam for that matter.

גמר חתימה טובה.

[doodle]

I never thought you did, nor did I get that impression from your posts above. Unfortunately the impression that came across was of you having a problem with a תקנה or הוספה בקודש instituted by certain tzaddikim (do you have a problem with daf hayomi?).

I hope this is all a misunderstanding, but you should be aware of the way it comes across.

גמר חתימה טובה.

There ARE  people who have a problem with Daf Yomi as a Takanah . Chas Vsholom . It's a nice thing , not a Takanah. Same should be with Psalms, or Tanya, It's a nice  thing to do , but it's not like Pesukai Dzimra or Shmah.