Chabad Minhagim: Pros & Cons

[gozalim]

Chabad house style?

talk about bubbles.

I'm not convivned none of the chazonim in 770 sing it/that I've never heard it there.

[ExGingi]

The overwhelming majority of Chabad shuls.

Totally dependent on who the chazan is, no? Aside from the niggunim like AM, or classics like Yaaleh, there are no rules for what gets sung and what tunes are used.

I wouldn't know. In the 38+ years since I came, I never davened anywhere but in 770 on ימים נוראים.

If the crowd is fanatical enough they tend to protest non-Chabad niggunim (has happened in 770, but definitely slips by more and more nowadays).

[gozalim]

I wouldn't know. In the 38+ years since I came, I never davened anywhere but in 770 on ימים נוראים.

If the crowd is fanatical enough they tend to protest non-Chabad niggunim (has happened in 770, but definitely slips by more and more nowadays).

what was והיה ביום ההוא יתקע yesterday?

[ExGingi]

this year they had some other pirchei tune going on in 770

Certain things we don't discuss in public...

[ExGingi]

what was והיה ביום ההוא יתקע yesterday?

I wasn't paying much attention to the details for reasons I will not discuss in this public forum. Let's just say that the Chazzan for Mussaf on the second day was unbelievable, and was heard in the entire shul.

But as I said, in recent years there's more instances of non-Chabad niggunim slipping by.

[gozalim]

But as I said, in recent years there's more instances of non-Chabad niggunim slipping by.

when the n00bs take over...

[gozalim]

Certain things we don't discuss in public...

if you wouldn't get so huffy about someone singing היום הרת being "chabad house style" (mind your 38 years in 770) we woudln't have to go there...

[ExGingi]

when the n00bs take over...

Who are you calling n00bs? The guys standing on the Bimah?

[Yehuda57]

I wouldn't know. In the 38+ years since I came, I never davened anywhere but in 770 on ימים נוראים.

If the crowd is fanatical enough they tend to protest non-Chabad niggunim (has happened in 770, but definitely slips by more and more nowadays).

Non Chabad tunes in 770 was done in front of the Rebbe

[ExGingi]

if you wouldn't get so huffy about someone singing היום הרת being "chabad house style" (mind your 38 years in 770) we woudln't have to go there...

cut @ExGingi some slack on a fast day.

[ExGingi]

Non Chabad tunes in 770 was done in front of the Rebbe

On occasion.

But we have become more fanatical over the years.

[Ver hut gazugt]

what was והיה ביום ההוא יתקע yesterday?

it’s a moshaich song so it’s different 

I hear gershen Mendal used to like that song a lot.

[ExGingi]

it’s a moshaich song so it’s different 

I hear gershen Mendal used to like that song a lot.

His favorite. Inscribed on his מצבה IINM.

[Yehuda57]

I wasn't paying much attention to the details for reasons I will not discuss in this public forum. Let's just say that the Chazzan for Mussaf on the second day was unbelievable, and was heard in the entire shul.

But as I said, in recent years there's more instances of non-Chabad niggunim slipping by.

I think you'll find that it only became a "thing" in relatively recent years and in the old days it was done without second thought. Some of the songs people think of as niggunim are borrowed tunes. HaRabbi Shlita is a TV show theme song for goodness sake.

[gozalim]

Who are you calling n00bs? The guys standing on the Bimah?

we have become more fanatical over the years.

[moko]

Famous machlokes between Reb Ahron and Rav Heinkin.

The reason to davka make kiddush is so not to fast past chatzos on Yom Tov if I recall correctly.

Mishnah Berurah (597:2)

[yelped]

I wouldn't know. In the 38+ years since I came, I never davened anywhere but in 770 on ימים נוראים.

If the crowd is fanatical enough they tend to protest non-Chabad niggunim (has happened in 770, but definitely slips by more and more nowadays).

There's a ton of "Chabad" niggunim that are borrowed from other places.

[ExGingi]

I think you'll find that it only became a "thing" in relatively recent years and in the old days it was done without second thought. Some of the songs people think of as niggunim are borrowed tunes. HaRabbi Shlita is a TV show theme song for goodness sake.

It's all about the journey the tune took on its way to get adopted.

[ExGingi]

There's a ton of "Chabad" niggunim that are borrowed appropriated from other places.

FTFY.

[Lurker]

There's a ton of "Chabad" niggunim that are borrowed from other places.

#fakenews. If every yid is a Lubavitcher, then every Jewish song....