Rooms regularly over $2k.It's a resort of only four rooms! https://onemileatatime.com/calala-island-nicaragua/
Christmas week is available, don't forget the 3 minimum night (sometimes more)
Not seeing it. Screenshot?
Screenshot_20191124-094952 by Jury Duty, on Flickr
I wonder if the difference in prices on the calala site is because of the different amount of rooms available
I feel like there's still hope for the end of 2020. Also, maybe call up the hotel to book dates that aren't available on Hyatt yet