All Halocha Shailos and Tiffeh Questions

[chinagel]

No, it is the way to keep it warm.

gotcha, so lfi zeh if i wanna bake s/t over shabbos in an oven in a case of hatmana it wouldnt be a problem?

[aygart]

gotcha, so lfi zeh if i wanna bake s/t over shabbos in an oven in a case of hatmana it wouldnt be a problem?

Tell me your case exactly.

[chinagel]

Tell me your case exactly.

its hypothetical, a classic case of hatmana just for baking instead of keeping warm

[aygart]

its hypothetical, a classic case of hatmana just for baking instead of keeping warm

You will need to do better than that. It is mutar to leave the food inside of an oven as long as it is not shehiya

[chinagel]

You will need to do better than that. It is mutar to leave the food inside of an oven as long as it is not shehiya

if hatmana is a chshash shema yechate what would be the difference btwn keeping it warm and actually baking

[aygart]

if hatmana is a chshash shema yechate what would be the difference btwn keeping it warm and actually baking

It is befeirush in the mishna that you may leave things in a kira that is garuf vkatum. I am not sure what your question is.

[churnbabychurn]

gotcha, so lfi zeh if i wanna bake s/t over shabbos in an oven in a case of hatmana it wouldnt be a problem?

Hatmana is wrapping food. Not an oven

[chinagel]

It is befeirush in the mishna that you may leave things in a kira that is garuf vkatum. I am not sure what your question is.

m"b 297, 5. in that case are you saying that if it was for cooking instead of keeping warm it would be mutar? if yes whats the difference? not sure why ur bringing in shehiya

[aygart]

m"b 297, 5. in that case are you saying that if it was for cooking instead of keeping warm it would be mutar? if yes whats the difference? not sure why ur bringing in shehiya

I am not getting your question.

[chinagel]

I am not getting your question.

theres an issur hatmana bdavar hamosif hevel shema yatmin b'efer. are you saying that that issur only applies when ur keeping s/t warn but if thats the way its cooked theres no problem? if yes why should cooking be different

[aygart]

theres an issur hatmana bdavar hamosif hevel shema yatmin b'efer. are you saying that that issur only applies when ur keeping s/t warn but if thats the way its cooked theres no problem? if yes why should cooking be different

Now I get it. He only says it regarding matmin of one food in another.

[chinagel]

Now I get it. He only says it regarding matmin of one food in another.

i didnt realize that, and by sous vide u would consider it one food in another even though the water is just being used for cooking?

[aygart]

i didnt realize that, and by sous vide u would consider it one food in another even though the water is just being used for cooking?

Why is it only for cooking?

[chinagel]

Why is it only for cooking?

youre right i just never thought like that but technically you can use the water for drinking
though i would think thats not usually how ppl are using it

[thaber]

Citation?

OC 2:50. Inference to siddur and chumash is not in the text, but I believe it is fairly simple, and IIRC I heard it from a posek

[ben89]

Reuven and shimon send Levi to the store to buy sushi. Reuven asks him to buy two rolls of $5 flavor and shimon asks Levi to buy one roll that cost $5.50 (different flavor). It ends up being that there's buy two get one free but Levi doesn't realize and pays $10.50 ($5.50 for the higher one plus $5 for the other). Reuven says he would have been more than happy to have a third roll free. How much does shimon owe? Does he have any chelek in the free one?
I need to find out more details but here's as much as I know. Obviously this would make a big difference with larger amounts of money so it's a general shailoh

[shulem92]

Reuven and shimon send Levi to the store to buy sushi. Reuven asks him to buy two rolls of $5 flavor and shimon asks Levi to buy one roll that cost $5.50 (different flavor). It ends up being that there's buy two get one free but Levi doesn't realize and pays $10.50 ($5.50 for the higher one plus $5 for the other). Reuven says he would have been more than happy to have a third roll free. How much does shimon owe? Does he have any chelek in the free one?
I need to find out more details but here's as much as I know. Obviously this would make a big difference with larger amounts of money so it's a general shailoh

If reuven had no idea about the promotion, then I would say levi could keep the 3rd roll (or in this case the money). Because he could have bought reuven his 2 rolls, kept the 3rd for himself, and bought Shimon a 4th roll...

[cholent]

If Shimon had no idea about the promotion, then I would say Reuven could keep the 3rd roll (or in this case the money). Because he could have bought Shimon his 2 rolls, kept the 3rd for himself, and bought Levi a 4th roll...

Read it again, your names are mixed up. I think you mean Levi could keep it

[shulem92]

Read it again, your names are mixed up. I think you mean Levi could keep it

Correct. I'll fix it

[Cheesecake]

If reuven had no idea about the promotion, then I would say levi could keep the 3rd roll (or in this case the money). Because he could have bought reuven his 2 rolls, kept the 3rd for himself, and bought Shimon a 4th roll...

Interesting. That might depend on whether or not Reuven and Shimon are considered to have jointly sent Levi, or each is a separate shlichus.

I would generally say the latter, but there might be a scenario in which it's the former.