All Halocha Shailos and Tiffeh Questions

[yitzgar]

See igros moshe cheilek aleph siman 33

I think R Moshe is talking about people who were frum, but had to work on shabbos. Here we are dealing with someone who isn't frum and just wants to come to shul. Our question just is if anything he did constitutes befarhesya or not.

[chbochur]

I think R Moshe is talking about people who were frum, but had to work on shabbos. Here we are dealing with someone who isn't frum and just wants to come to shul. Our question just is if anything he did constitutes befarhesya or not.

Then there's no real question he's a tinok shenishboh.

[yesitsme]

Is going out to make a phone call or driving to shul & parking a block away considered בפרהסיה ?

What if the phone call was a טעות עכום? True story

[yitzgar]

Then there's no real question he's a tinok shenishboh.

First of all, that is t necessarily true, but regardless, it has nothing to do with this. Did you read R Moshe's tshuva you posted? If he did a maaseh of chillul shabbos publicly, that is a maaseh kefira and is considered a mumar, even if you have reason to believe that he is really just doing it letayavon

[yitzgar]

What if the phone call was a טעות עכום? True story

What does this mean?

[yesitsme]

What does this mean?

Someone answered the phone on shabbos (old man not sure if he knew the day of the week) everyone was like what was that all about, he said a guy had the wrong number so they said, so its a ......

[chbochur]

First of all, that is t necessarily true, but regardless, it has nothing to do with this. Did you read R Moshe's tshuva you posted? If he did a maaseh of chillul shabbos publicly, that is a maaseh kefira and is considered a mumar, even if you have reason to believe that he is really just doing it letayavon

But then reb moshe clarifies why in a case where there's reason to say that it was leteiovon we assume that it was for that reason and he isn't being a kofer. Now if that's true regarding someone going to work how much more so it's true to someone who is driving to shul.

[chbochur]

Someone answered the phone on shabbos (old man not sure if he knew the day of the week) everyone was like what was that all about, he said a guy had the wrong number so they said, so its a ......

He could have been a doctor...

[PlatinumGuy]

Where do you see that? Just that the vast majority of non-observant are not, not that there's no such thing.
Besides, the question was about a mechalel shabbos iinm.

Read the screenshot I posted.

The Chazon Ash says Mechalel Shabbos is not considered Mumar etc until he does so in the face of תוכחה, and since there is no תוכחה nowadays all are anusim.


That may not be the prevailing opinion but there is no question it is what the Chazon Ish says.
 

Then there's no real question he's a tinok shenishboh.

R Elyashiv and others dispute that, since knoweldge of Shabbos is fairly widespread.

[yesitsme]

He could have been a doctor...

He wasnt a stranger, it was an old יוצאי רוסיא with a cane
Engineer would fit better

[chinagel]

Read the screenshot I posted.

The Chazon Ash says Mechalel Shabbos is not considered Mumar etc until he does so in the face of תוכחה, and since there is no תוכחה nowadays all are anusim.


That may not be the prevailing opinion but there is no question it is what the Chazon Ish says.
 
R Elyashiv and others dispute that, since knoweldge of Shabbos is fairly widespread.

I see now.

[TimT]

May one put on new suits, shirts, pants this shabbos ?

[Ver hut gazugt]

May one put on new suits, shirts, pants this shabbos ?

You can put it on now 

[TimT]

You can put it on now 

Its ok during the 3 weeks ?

[Ver hut gazugt]

Its ok during the 3 weeks ?

My bad no can’t in three weeks. I can’t remember if it’s the three weeks or sefira where we specifically get new cloths or try to make shehechiyanu at least in Chabad.

[Yikes2179]

Its ok during the 3 weeks ?

If you wouldn't make a שהחיינו it's fine

[chbochur]

My bad no can’t in three weeks. I can’t remember if it’s the three weeks or sefira where we specifically get new cloths or try to make shehechiyanu at least in Chabad.

Rosh Hashanah maybe?

[chbochur]

If you wouldn't make a שהחיינו it's fine

Not during the nine days though

[EliJelly]

You can put it on now 

Definitely the way to go for shirts and pants. Suits is more of a question although some pasken that;

If you wouldn't make a שהחיינו it's fine

And that leniency is also to wear it first today. Not allowed in the nine days, even Shabbos.

[TimT]

https://vinnews.com/2021/07/11/the-16-people-who-cant-be-counted-for-a-minyan/