All Halocha Shailos and Tiffeh Questions

[churnbabychurn]

• RA"E in the addition at the end of the tshuva seems to write that he is referring to someone who leaves for a few days and not just someone who steps outside for a few minutes.

I work way out of lakewood. so arguably this could apply.

[churnbabychurn]

I'm maskim to your lomdus, and that birchas haroeh is different.
However, the reason not to eat is not (only)  because you have a chiyuv that was chal. For example, even if for whatever reason you can't shake lulav now, or daven mincha, a seudah is lechoaira still assur. (Before you jump on me, I know that איו הנידון דומה לראיה because there the chiyuv is chal, just no heicha timza, and here there's no chiyuv, but in both cases I can't do it now and will be able to do it later).
 I'm not sure why, but maybe because there's still a chashash it'll totally slip your mind if you get busy with something else.
lehalacha, they bring this in the dirshu from Reb Vosner (p.110 in the miluim, #31) However in the same shtikel they bring from RNK that a woman can't eat even if she is someich on her husband "since she is in the makom hadlaka" That would seem to be a rayoh to your yesod. I don't have the quoted seforim on hand to look up though.

To add the issur achila begins half hour before the chiyuv... So maybe you have a point..

[churnbabychurn]

גם יש לדון אם יש להמשרד או הרכב - שלפעמים גם אוכל בהם סעודות וכו' - דין דירה. . וממקום שבאת, הרי המשרד חייב במזוזה  וגם הרכב הי' חייב לכמה פוסקים אם 'הי' בה שיעור דע"ד ושאר התנאים

Indeed iirc there is a R Shlomo Zalman about lighting a flash light on a plane for ner chanuka...

[aygart]

Tos: "they were mesaken bircas haroeh for people who dont have a house and are not able to be mekayem the mitzva. .... Vtikshey lei mezuza."

Clearly this teritz of tos is suggesting that chanuka is a chiyuv like mezuza.
What say you?



Indeed, achsanai may be only a chiyuv mishum chshad, etc. (delo K'hRan.)

I meant ishto madlekes olov and being mitztaref with a pruta.

[dealfinder85]

Tos: "they were mesaken bircas haroeh for people who dont have a house and are not able to be mekayem the mitzva. .... Vtikshey lei mezuza."

Clearly this teritz of tos is suggesting that chanuka is a chiyuv like mezuza.
What say you?



Indeed, achsanai may be only a chiyuv mishum chshad, etc. (delo K'hRan.)

its similar to mezuza in that you only have a chiyuv if you have a bayis
its different than mezuza in that, to use terminology born from nedarim, the chiyuv hadlaka is a chiyuv on the gavra and the chiyuv mezuza is on the cheftza of the bayis

[eliraps]

I am new to this side of DDF. How do you guys write inyonim of learning in english???
It would take me 5 times as long to write...

I have been teaching inyonim of halacha to people without enough background to understand concepts not presented in standard english for quite a few years. It is not difficult to do the same in writing.

I also teach people who do not have a yeshiva background. indeed it takes 5 times as long....

[churnbabychurn]

Takes me too long to type Hebrew.

[TimT]

Forgive me if this was covered already, if someone must work late is he allowed to eat anything he wants or not ?

[FlyFirst]

Forgive me if this was covered already, if someone must work late is he allowed to eat anything he wants or not ?

Had the same question, my Rav told me not to eat after the 72

[eliraps]

Forgive me if this was covered already, if someone must work late is he allowed to eat anything he wants or not ?

I assume this means that there are some posts that you don't know about?! I'm speechless!
On a serious note, I've been meaning for a long time to PM you to tell you how much I benefit from all your cross-referencing and mare mekomos, and how much I appreciate your input. But here's to a public thank you!

[TimT]

I assume this means that there are some posts that you don't know about?! I'm speechless!
On a serious note, I've been meaning for a long time to PM you to tell you how much I benefit from all your cross-referencing and mare mekomos, and how much I appreciate your input. But here's to a public thank you!

YW. There was a lot of back & forth lomdos & hebrew that was just confusing me.

[TimT]

Had the same question, my Rav told me not to eat after the 72

So you gotta go hungry till whatever hour you get home to light.

[churnbabychurn]

So you gotta go hungry till whatever hour you get home to light.

Should be able to appoint a shomer if necessary.

[eliraps]

So you gotta go hungry till whatever hour you get home to light.

http://www.easyfasts.com/categories/Kali-Zom-Easy-Fasting-Pill/ 

[churnbabychurn]

So you gotta go hungry till whatever hour you get home to light.

And as long as you are not koveia a seuda you are fine. Ie kabeitza+ mezonos or washing.

[TimT]

http://www.easyfasts.com/categories/Kali-Zom-Easy-Fasting-Pill/ 

Only if I remember to take it before 72.

[aygart]

Had the same question, my Rav told me not to eat after the 72

That is interesting bacause many poskim say not to eat for half an hour beforehand. Also, that would depend on your minhag of when to light.

[TimT]

That is interesting bacause many poskim say not to eat for half an hour beforehand. Also, that would depend on your minhag of when to light.

Half hour before whenever you plan to light ?

[aygart]

Half hour before whenever you plan to light ?

before zman hadlaka

[churnbabychurn]

Said yaleh vayovo in shachris by mistake?