Other people. First guy I definitely hear.
Also I’m not sure why I took this OT, just saw talk about people not having antibodies and therefore being excluded from yeshiva. Now I see people are making another level of people who were exposed but didn’t get anything and are therefore less worried
They are definitely misguided but there is at least an argument to be made. If the theory that some people may be less susceptible to catching the virus altogether (for example, due to exposure to previous coronaviruses) is true, then strong previous exposure can be used as anecdotal evidence that this person is more likely to fall into that category.
Of course, it’s at best a theory, and even if the theory is true their lack of contracting the virus previously in no way necessarily means that they are of that category, it just means they failed to catch it yet for some reason, of which one may be that they’re less susceptible.
So yes, they’re definitely misguided (and likely under informed), but there is at least a scientific possibility that they have a point.