How much milk do you have in your fridge?

[EliJelly]

Cheese is complex halachically. While some authorities permit drinking chalov stam (and using it to make cheese), NO authorities (to my knowledge) allow gevinas akum. A Jew MUST be present during the cheese-making process.

Even non-cholav-Yisroel cheeses must be made under the supervision of a Jew in order to be certified Kosher. There are a number of brands that make cheese with non-cholav-Yisroel milk, as it is substantially cheaper. But they all are Gevinas Yisroel.

I'm not a rabbi but this is my understanding of the situation.

Well, still non cholov yisroel is way way cheaper.

Ete. A single search shows a Breakstone's 48 oz cottage cheese tub for $4.99 online! And it has an OU-D. I pay more for a Mehadrin 16 oz.

[justaregularguy]

Are there no big American cheese companies with an OU-D? I never checked but I'd assume there is.
Anyways, Costco CY cheese is limited to some mozzarella cheese. No cottage, farmer or American cheese. 

Ete. A single search shows a Breakstone's 48 oz cottage cheese tub for $4.99 online! And it has an OU-D. I pay more for a Mehadrin 16 oz.

I must point out here that if you eat cottage cheese , you eat friendships (large curd), not breakstones. Sorry

[Dan]

Well, still non cholov yisroel is way way cheaper.

Talking about cheese. Not cottage cheese.

[EliJelly]

I must point out here that if you eat cottage cheese , you eat friendships (large curd), not breakstones. Sorry

No. Mehadrin is small curd too

[yesitsme]

Talking about cheese. Not cottage cheese.

Don't get me started 😂
My wife: cheese = American cheese, there's also cottage cheese
Me: cheese = cottage cheese, there's also American cheese

Pstt, please buy cheese, sure np, cheese not cottage, oh just say so. 

[AsherO]

Ouch, still high.

Isn’t POTF extra heavy/yummy milk? Or am I confusing it with a different brand?

[YitzyS]

Isn’t POTF extra heavy/yummy milk? Or am I confusing it with a different brand?

As they say about milk and humans: no smell is the best smell...

[yitzgar]

Don't get me started
My wife: cheese = American cheese, there's also cottage cheese
Me: cheese = cottage cheese, there's also American cheese

Pstt, please buy cheese, sure np, cheese not cottage, oh just say so.

Neither of those are "cheese"

[Dan]

Neither of those are "cheese"

+1

[aygart]

As they say about milk and humans: no smell is the best smell...

Except that POTF tastes much better. I haven't yet found someone who disagrees.

[aygart]

FWIW, when they used to sell POTF gallons in ShorRite they were actually cheaper than the regular milk gallons. I used to see non-Jews who figured that out buying POTF.

[AsherO]

FWIW, when they used to sell POTF gallons in ShorRite they were actually cheaper than the regular milk gallons. I used to see non-Jews who figured that out buying POTF.

[aygart]

Hard to imagine, huh? But it actually happened!

[CountValentine]

Except that POTF tastes much better. I haven't yet found someone who disagrees.

...because I haven't tried it.
POTF?

[avromie7]

...because I haven't tried it.
POTF?

Pride of the Farm. It's produced by Kreider Farms in PA.