New Chassidish Community Being Planned in Tampa

[Jellybelly]

Yea I hope they get a good Rav/manhig

[mendyt]

The only new successful communities for Jewish ppl in the usa and outside, were ones that were geared toward a specific group.

If I'm missing something please let me know.

Look at Bloomingrove, Blumingburg, Viznits in Kiamesha Lake,  would you consider these communities successful?!

[KSMH]

Look at Bloomingrove, Blumingburg, Viznits in Kiamesha Lake,  would you consider these communities successful?!

I didn't say all were successful but did say the ones that were had that component to it.

Also, how do you define success?

[mendyt]

I didn't say all were successful but did say the ones that were had that component to it.

Also, how do you define success?

I would define success if it's a community that keeps on growing and people want to join it, plus it has their own mosdos and everything around it.
All these communities have their 100-150 families and that's where it ended.

[ExGingi]

Hope it will. High time we got ourselves out of the tri state area.

So did you sign up as a founding member?

[KSMH]

I would define success if it's a community that keeps on growing and people want to join it, plus it has their own mosdos and everything around it.
All these communities have their 100-150 families and that's where it ended.

My point of, the successful one's happen to be those geared towards a specific community, still stands. Its possible some failed [according to some people's designation], but the ones that succeeded had those components.

[Lurker]

I wish they could do this somewhere I drop closer. Is there no decent area within a 5 hr drive of the tristate? Pennsylvania?

Different people have tried to do versions of this in PA, DE, MD, andVA over the last 15 years that know of. A few times they got very close, with houses actually under construction, before falling apart. Many times, education was a big issue with local governments. This group seems to have reached a compromise with local authorities, so I believe they have a better chance at success.

[mendyt]

My point of, the successful one's happen to be those geared towards a specific community, still stands. Its possible some failed [according to some people's designation], but the ones that succeeded had those components.

I dont know which community you have in mind, but I'm not aware of any besides in Israel which you cant compare.
And we need a solution for all chasidim not just one group, that doesnt help in any way.

[KSMH]

I dont know which community you have in mind, but I'm not aware of any besides in Israel which you cant compare.
And we need a solution for all chasidim not just one group, that doesnt help in any way.

I dont have anything specific in mind, but the general concept.

Instead of looking for new communities and fancy marketing from brokers, find a place that u can call home without the hype.

There are enough out there.

[mushkovits]

My point of, the successful one's happen to be those geared towards a specific community, still stands. Its possible some failed [according to some people's designation], but the ones that succeeded had those components.

Heard of Staten Island?

[yungermanchik]

Heard of Staten Island?

That wasn't truly making a new community. It was taking over an existing YI community and expanding it.

[ah giten]

Look at Bloomingrove, Blumingburg, Viznits in Kiamesha Lake,  would you consider these communities successful?!

All of these are growing, might be a longer process, but look at KJ, is that called success?

[Yehuda25]

All of these are growing, might be a longer process, but look at KJ, is that called success?

wild success

[Something Fishy]

All of these are growing, might be a longer process, but look at KJ, is that called success?

LOL, you're comparing Gibbers to KJ?

[points 99]

wild success

was that and/or