I would say that for MMM4, but I think that The Lost Treasure is a masterpiece.
I would assume that its only flaw is that it wasn't released when you were a child, so you don't have any nostalgic feelings attached to it.
That's definitely true, about the nostalgia.
(Not to make this an Abie thread, but the following releases were all arguably disappointing:
- Lev Vnefesh 2
- Dveykus 6
- Journeys 4 (arguably, I said!)
- MM4
- Aish 2 & 3
- Lost Treasure (IMO!)
Which basically covers his releases over the past 15-20 years.
Guess he's more focused on his literary career
)