Thrifty.com is generally by far the cheapest, $12/day insurance, 14+/day for the car, check their site. It is Albar in Israel. With the MCW, you have CDW but you have to pay the 3PLC of 12/day. Without the MCW, you can pay almost the same price but you will have a deductible of approx. 500 whereas with the MCW, it is a few dollars cheaper, no deductible, but the car rental charges for damage and the client gets repaid from the cc. See the T&C's on the site.
The issue is I think that there may be a peak season surcharge of 12/day.
Noach car can get pretty good rates, in my experience from Hertz through NoachCar I got upgrades and you should get points from Hertz #1 Gold Club if you rent from Hertz through NC.