there wasn't any fraud but the they needed to jump through hoops to get there.
Like I said similar to the garbage the govt pulled with PUA "overpayment"
You're making some very dubious allegations without any substance. It's precisely nonsense like this that needs to be stopped because you're misinforming other people and potentially scaring them off.
- "It's an unwritten policy to deny claims"
- "There's a whole slew of reasons that can put you at odds"
- "Many companies first resort to denying and only pay when confronted"
- "The default was to claim fraud"
- "There wasn't any fraud".... trust me bro
I'll point out that you're discussing this with people who are very knowledgeable about life insurance, so the bar for sounding believable is a lot higher than when you tell over these stories at your Shabbos table.
I am very interested in what you have to say, and in continuing the discussion, but I think you need to provide some detail that goes beyond "trust me bro"
1) You claimed that there are a bunch of reasons that can put you at odds with the insurance company, but you haven't yet told us what they are. What are those reasons? Feel free to copy/paste from an insurance policy. Every single legitimate life insurance policy is publicly filed so you can look up and post from any company you choose. I've drafted and proofread dozens of policy forms over the years, so I'm definitely qualified to discuss it with you.
2) What fraud did the insurance company claim occurred? They are required to be specific (per the regulation except below, which similar to the standard in every jurisdiction).
2b) And what do your friends say was the real story?
3) Did you contact the State Insurance Department about the contested policies? They are very consumer friendly and will always favor the customer over the insurance company when there is a gray area. It's not at all like having a dispute with the IRS.
4) After the claims were paid, did you report the insurance company for making you jump through hoops? There severe penalties for unfair claims practices.
Fair Claims Settlement Practices requires that, "Every insurer that denies or rejects a claim in whole or in part, or disputes liability or damages, shall provide to the claimant a written statement listing all bases for such rejection or denial, and the factual and legal bases for each reason given for each rejection or denial, which are within the insurer's knowledge."
As a better known poster often says, put up or shut up.
Feel free to PM