I have a long standing opinion which you have seen numerous times that there is little a president can do to change the economy other than get out of the way and even that has limited effect. In my post above I mentioned how the economy did well under Clinton and Obama.
Even in your imaginary world of presidents controlling things, using a metric which was almost entirely due to a global pandemic is simply silly.
All I did was state facts that are indisputable. Now everyone can decide what influence the president has on the economy, market, unemployment and other things.
Every president needs to handle a crisis. Having 500k+ die, economy tank, unemployment go through the roof is a failure on all fronts.
Now if you want to say rising gas prices is a crisis failure so be it.