I bought the expensive all leather All-ett ($80 minus 10% off) and the cheap All-ett one ~$20. I use them in combination with a thin Dopp wallet.
The all-leather all-ett contains all my cards I use during the week -- Sapphire, Freedoms, SPG Amex, Hilton Amex, Insurance cards, elevator card, AAA card, Costco card, license, amusement park passes and gift cards.
The cheap all-ett sits at home and holds cards I never use -- expired Amex Plat, Authorized user cards, etc.
The slim Dopp is used when I go out to dinner (only license, AAA, Sapphire, Freedom and SPG).