Is It Ethical?

[meshugener]

Why not?

[buggie]

cuz isnt the whole idea to differntiate between married women

[meshugener]

If that's the reason I don't see how you can wear a shaitel in first place.

[kracked dude]

is it ethical to wear a shaitel with a fake skin in front that makes (or any other thing to that effect)a shaitel look for real

Why is this an ethical question? Maybe post in the halacha thread

[meshugener]

In any case, this is the ethical thread, not halacha/minhag.

[CountValentine]

Why is this an ethical question?

...because most here don't understand the difference between ethics and religion. 

[buggie]

it seems cv is one of em -that is the not understanding   vein kan hamakom leharich

[YankyDoodle]

it seems cv is one of em -that is the not understanding   vein kan hamakom leharich

It seems you are trying to argue that halacha (religion) is ethics. You are not incorrect. The problem is that halacha can only be considered "ethics" if you consider halacha to be true. There are plenty that do not consider that the case (see most non-Jews and plenty of Jews as well), and therefore an ethics thread such as this must be based on truths that can be intuited without a prior fundamental belief.

[CountValentine]

It seems you are trying to argue that halacha (religion) is ethics. You are not incorrect. The problem is that halacha can only be considered "ethics" if you consider halacha to be true. There are plenty that do not consider that the case (see most non-Jews and plenty of Jews as well), and therefore an ethics thread such as this must be based on truths that can be intuited without a prior fundamental belief.

Going to have to hire you as my writer. 

[Achas Veachas]

I hope we are not restarting this argument again...
Wake me up in 10 pages lol

[YankyDoodle]

Going to have to hire you as my writer. 

I'm not cheap... It would take at least a roll of Shallot's sushi 

[CountValentine]

I hope we are not restarting this argument again...
Wake me up in 10 pages lol

They will only be half way through. 

[CountValentine]

I'm not cheap... It would take at least a roll of Shallot's sushi 

If that's all it will take then I will deliver also. Do they have tamper proof tape like Milt's? 

[YankyDoodle]

If that's all it will take then I will deliver also. Do they have tamper proof tape like Milt's? 

Alol!

[dans fan]

...because most here don't understand the difference between ethics and religion. 

i can use a writer myself but i will try to explain you my point. the reason why most here dont understand the difference is because most here are jewish and in our religion we dont decide what is ethical because pretty much all ethics are disussed and have a source so ppl here have a answer based on religion

[CountValentine]

i can use a writer myself but i will try to explain you my point. the reason why most here dont understand the difference is because most here are jewish and in our religion we dont decide what is ethical because pretty much all ethics are disussed and have a source so ppl here have a answer based on religion

I fully understand your point. Your religion like my religion decides if something is ethical or not based on its teachings. I am able to think outside my religion. Someone that can’t think outside their religion has been brainwashed.

[AJK]

You make the false assumption that an individual who chooses not to think outside their religion is incapable of doing so.

Many on here have done the former, while being quite capable of doing the latter.

[CountValentine]

You make the false assumption...

AFAIK I didn't assume anything this time.

[AJK]

Well only you would know if you assumed something, but it should did seem that you implicitly did so.

[CountValentine]

Well only you would know if you assumed something, but it should did seem that you implicitly did so.

Sentence:
1 - fact
2 - AFAIK fact
3 - fact
4 - statement