Which hagagdah do you use? (to prepare for/lead the seder) + Share a DT

[Eliyohu]

I just realized this year. It says hashata hacha lshana haba...
But usually it's pronounced hashta not hashata. IDK what's different in dikduk

Hashta means now HaShata means this year.

There are different girsaos in the rishonim... the mesivta hagdah mentions them as well as brings multiple explanations why we'd be asking for something next year and not now this year.

[HudZ]

Does everyone ask this question at their Seder?

Why don't we make a Beracha on the Haggadah?

[aygart]

There are different girsaos in the rishonim... the mesivta hagdah mentions them as well as brings multiple explanations why we'd be asking for something next year and not now this year.

Also discussed by Maharal in Gevuros Hashem end of 51

[Eliyohu]

Also discussed by Maharal in Gevuros Hashem end of 51

Indeed,
..  hagadas shlaima from R Kasher is a good mareh makom

Hu Shata can also be a contraction of הא שעתא or הא שעה. So the nikkud doesn't necessarily give it away.

(There are those who say at the end of achienu the proper term there is hu shata; as well. There the order of hasta ba'agala ub'zman kariv would need to be explained. )

[Yehuda57]

Yeah every kid comes home with that gematriya every year

I was mistaken. It doesn't say this gematriya in the Rebbe's haggada, it *does* say it is referring to the havtacha.

[SuperFlyer]

A must is the Hakdamah on the Haggadah by the Malbim. (Note: not printed in every Haggadah!).

It explains how the seemingly totally awkward order in the Haggadah makes perfect sense.

People who read this, do not understand how one could have made the Seder without.

The Pashtus of my upload of the Hakdama is signature Malbim.


https://drive.google.com/file/d/1gYSriB56wIvs4M2f4q0Q_hNdw165qH9n/view?usp=drivesdk


If it's too much to read, start from page י"ט

[YitzyS]

A must is the Hakdamah on the Haggadah by the Malbim. (Note: not printed in every Haggadah!).

It explains how the seemingly totally awkward order in the Haggadah makes perfect sense.

If there is demand for it here, I shall try to post.

A must is the Hakdamah on the Haggadah by the Malbim. (Note: not printed in every Haggadah!).

It explains how the seemingly totally awkward order in the Haggadah makes perfect sense.

People who read this, do not understand how one could have made the Seder without.

The Pashtus of my upload of the Hakdama is signature Malbim.


https://drive.google.com/file/d/1gYSriB56wIvs4M2f4q0Q_hNdw165qH9n/view?usp=drivesdk


If it's too much to read, start from page י"ט

Thanks for adding the upload! I could not find it printed previously.

This is a fascinatingly brilliant and equally simple thing, yet I've told it over to tens of people of the last decade and NONE of them ever thought of it, nor heard of it, before.

I heard that it's in the Malbim Haggadah, but I have not found it inside yet. Do you know where I can find it. (I heard it originally, but never read it.)

[Jack Last]

Maybe a little late... I use the Nachlas Tzvi Hagadda and can't reccomend it enough very easy Artscroll like translation in Hebrew - while explaining the flow of the hagaadah at every step! (with footnotes mostly from Rishonim and early Achronim.)
Under the line on the right side you have some interesting Hassidic notes which I honestly never read...

[cholent]

A must is the Hakdamah on the Haggadah by the Malbim. (Note: not printed in every Haggadah!).

It explains how the seemingly totally awkward order in the Haggadah makes perfect sense.

People who read this, do not understand how one could have made the Seder without.

The Pashtus of my upload of the Hakdama is signature Malbim.


https://drive.google.com/file/d/1gYSriB56wIvs4M2f4q0Q_hNdw165qH9n/view?usp=drivesdk


If it's too much to read, start from page י"ט

Every year I want to take the time to learn this before Pesach and every year I can't find the time during the busiest time of year.

[avromie7]

Every year I want to take the time to learn this before Pesach and every year I can't find the time during the busiest time of year.

This year you have shabbos.

[cholent]

This year you have shabbos.

My favorite calendar setup, so I can take a nap and not fall asleep during the seder. Definitely the most important seder prep

[SuperFlyer]

Every year I want to take the time to learn this before Pesach and every year I can't find the time during the busiest time of year.

Print it.
Plus I wrote a shortcut if it is too long.

[HudZ]

[cholent]

Print it.
Plus I wrote a shortcut if it is too long.

I'm feeding it two pages at a time to AI to translate to English

[Yehuda57]

My favorite calendar setup, so I can take a nap and not fall asleep during the seder. Definitely the most important seder prep

Preparing for the seder on shabbos?

[SuperFlyer]

I'm feeding it two pages at a time to AI to translate to English

Interested to see the result please.