Israel vs. Iran And Proxies: War Discussion Master Thread

[Kobe Bryant]

Unverified rumors at this point, though Bibi did say Israel had offered a deal but didn’t specify the terms, might or might not be referring to this:

https://x.com/jokermanintel/status/1749525486949257580

Rejected by Hamas (AP)

[zalman2bis]

The Yidden listening to Biden have the blood of these soldiers on their hands

FTFM. Maybe for you as well. Don't remember hearing the Rebbe blaming the presidents of US. Usually blaming the Jewish leaders for caving to political pressure.

[Dan]

https://twitter.com/piersmorgan/status/1749764565057814686

[TimT]

1 of yesterday’s fallen heroes.

https://twitter.com/ariwaxman/status/1749754206192374260

[AsherO]

1 of yesterday’s fallen heroes.

https://twitter.com/ariwaxman/status/1749754206192374260

What a hero! See the parting letter he wrote to his family:
https://www.ynet.co.il/news/article/syiuizpfa

[yelped]

Seeing lots of these all over:

https://twitter.com/Joe_Roberts01/status/1749912893359899108

[yelped]

https://twitter.com/persianjewess/status/1749889716366033124

[ExGingi]

HY"D.

Interesting read.

https://x.com/sivanhakolkalul/status/1749870313184047470

[Mordyk]

I see all over hostage families protesting etc.  I feel terrible and my heart goes out to them. And I'm not judging in the least but. But what do they think we can do more to get the hostages out? Israel went to disassemble gaza, they tried to negotiate with hamas.

What else is there really to do?  Release every single Arab in Israeli prisons? Give in to every hamas request?  This is such a sad scenario.   Could be I don't really understand the Israeli politics and there is more

[ExGingi]

I see all over hostage families protesting etc.  I feel terrible and my heart goes out to them. And I'm not judging in the least but. But what do they think we can do more to get the hostages out? Israel went to disassemble gaza, they tried to negotiate with hamas.

What else is there really to do?  Release every single Arab in Israeli prisons? Give in to every hamas request?  This is such a sad scenario.   Could be I don't really understand the Israeli politics and there is more

The protests are funded/led by the same people who funded/led the anti judicial reform protests. It's about toppling the government. Can't judge the families. But anyone with an ounce of brains understands that the protests are counterproductive to the cause of hostage release.

[AsherO]

The protests are funded/led by the same people who funded/led the anti judicial reform protests. It's about toppling the government. Can't judge the families. But anyone with an ounce of brains understands that the protests are counterproductive to the cause of hostage release.

Which only makes these funders/leaders who are politicizing the hostage situation only more sinister.

[ExGingi]

Which only makes these funders/leaders who are politicizing the hostage situation only more sinister.

They don't care. They have no morals. They consider themselves demi-gods (to say the least). Think George Soros and his ilk.

[Moshe Green]

They don't care. They have no morals. They consider themselves demi-gods (to say the least). Think George Soros and his ilk.

The one thing they DONT WANT is to free the hostages.
Then they can't protest against Netanyahu.

[yelped]

https://twitter.com/Aizenberg55/status/1750162910758764826

[JMHO]

I see all over hostage families protesting etc.  I feel terrible and my heart goes out to them. And I'm not judging in the least but. But what do they think we can do more to get the hostages out? Israel went to disassemble gaza, they tried to negotiate with hamas.

What else is there really to do?  Release every single Arab in Israeli prisons? Give in to every hamas request?  This is such a sad scenario.   Could be I don't really understand the Israeli politics and there is more

To quite the Brisker Rav, 'whenever someone is in pain, they don’t sit around and strategize, they scream and cry!'
So that is how the families R"L and people who are on that level of pain are expressing themselves right now.

Like others have said, the 'protest organizers' are sick and will use every opportunity to promote their own agenda.

[yitzgar]

Just to point out, for all the criticism of the anti judicial reform protesters, many from that camp have realized that now is an inappropriate time to protest, and have joined supporting the country's goals in the current war. Take Eylon Levi for example

[yfr bachur]

Which only makes these funders/leaders who are politicizing the hostage situation only more sinister.

And the opposition leader is no better. Just anti, anti bibi without offering what exactly he would do differently.

This "hostage deal now at all costs" movement is just stupid - and someone in the mainstream "leadership" should say so
So hamas says they'll release the hostages if 500-800 random israeli citzens are exocuted... would you still say do the deal?
what about giving them be'eri and nachal oz?

[aygart]

https://apnews.com/article/israel-palestinians-gaza-genocide-africa-court-fa3e8aca5c2b90871c6c78b10bc276b6

[Kobe Bryant]

Tanya being printed in Gaza now.

Another Tanya was printed today in Kahn Yunis.

[WayBackMachine]

Another Tanya was printed today in Kahn Yunis.

okay