A Rally in Honor... Mohamed Merah Yimach Shemo

[AJK]

+1 we're not looking for fights or rants, just trying to have an ideological debate.

@SuperFlyer I want to hear how to you can philosophically differentiate the following..

Differentiate for me the commandment of timche Amalek (that in today's day and age is looked at as biblical genocide), which was the killing of an entire race, we were commanded to kill woman and children. If one can understand that mitzvah (which to be frank I don't, but that could just be me, and if I were asked today to kill someone today that is 1000% a decedent from Amalek I would say "sorry no-can-do"), explain to me as if I were an impartial outsider why that is different then the minds of these twisted Muslim terrorists that truly believe they are doing G-ds will, and they have been brain washed that all non-muslims are the "Amalek" and have to be wiped out completely.

+1

Now we're talking - A point I would've made to someone willing to engage in mature discussion.

[Mocha]

Lets rephrase, The year 1944, would you understand a commandment to kill the germans?

Woman and children? Hell no. Nazi soldiers? Definitely

[meshugener]

Mr. Marcez, based on your last line I believe you still live in the 19th century. Welcome to the 21st century! We have a lot of good stuff out here! Feel free to explore your new world! What do you want? Have you ever heard about the automobile? The telephone? These are very usefull products! Try it!

[SuperFlyer]

Woman and children? Hell no. Nazi soldiers? Definitely

Lets rephrase again: you go with a time machine and an ak47 back to the year 1891, and adolf yimach shemoi is 2 years old. Can you kill him?

[mercaz1]

Mr. Marcez, based on your last line I believe you still live in the 19th century. Welcome to the 21st century! We have a lot of good stuff out here! Feel free to explore your new world! What do you want? Have you ever heard about the automobile? The telephone? These are very usefull products! Try it!

how is that an answer to what i said
25 years is a drop in the bucket if you study history.
the muslims have still not killed as many as hitler or stalin or mao- is germany or russia or china consiudered a rotten country now- maybe but not definitley
so in another 25 years muslims might not be considered rotten either

[mercaz1]

Lets rephrase again: you go with a time machine and an ak47 back to the year 1891, and adolf yimach shemoi is 2 years old. Can you kill him?

would you kill him first or try and make him normal first

[HelpMe]

Differentiate for me the commandment of timche Amalek (that in today's day and age is looked at as biblical genocide), which was the killing of an entire race, we were commanded to kill woman and children. If one can understand that mitzvah (which to be frank I don't, but that could just be me, and if I were asked today to kill someone today that is 1000% a decedent from Amalek I would say "sorry no-can-do"), explain to me as if I were an impartial outsider why that is different than the minds of these twisted Muslim terrorists that truly believe they are doing G-ds will, and they have been brain-washed that all non-Muslims are the "Amalek" and have to be wiped out completely.

Is this going on today?

[Side incomer]

would you kill him first or try and make him normal first

Make normal Hitler?
Can you believe you wrote these words?

[mercaz1]

if he is 2 years old why not
we are discussing hypothetically here

[Mocha]

Lets rephrase again: you go with a time machine and an ak47 back to the year 1891, and adolf yimach shemoi is 2 years old. Can you kill him?

I don't know. I would like to say yes because he killed millions of my people, but I don't think I can take a dagger to a 2 year olds chest for any reason. But where is this question going?

Is this going on today?

Lol no dude, chilax.

[meshugener]

Hitler, Stalin and Mao were not in the last 25 years "if you study history"

[AJK]

But where is this question going?

It isn't going anywhere. It's a red herring from your great point above.

why that is different than the minds of these twisted Muslim terrorists that truly believe they are doing G-ds will, and they have been brain-washed that all non-Muslims are the "Amalek" and have to be wiped out completely.

[mercaz1]

i realize that but im saying that in another 25 years there might be another sect of people or nation whoi will take over from the muslims to be rotten maybe
i donbt really think so but it is possible

[Mocha]

Hitler, Stalin and Mao were not in the last 25 years "if you study history"

i realize that but im saying that in another 25 years there might be another sect of people or nation whoi will take over from the muslims to be rotten maybe
i donbt really think so but it is possible

Can both of you please quote who your responding to? Thanks

[AJK]

how is that an answer to what i said
25 years is a drop in the bucket if you study history.
the muslims have still not killed as many as hitler or stalin or mao- is germany or russia or china consiudered a rotten country now- maybe but not definitley
so in another 25 years muslims might not be considered rotten either

Hitler, Stalin and Mao were not in the last 25 years "if you study history"

Who cares? 25 years, 50 years, 100 years? The point is the same.