Are you keeping one day of yom tov?

[Red]

This isn't ma'aras ayin.

FWIU that is the issue with doing melacha in chul.

[shmuelb]

If you want to know what is the halacha, ask your Rav. For a heter to do what you want, ask ____ or click on this link ... etc or call 1-800-dialaheter 

Yup, I keep one day!

btw, when browsing ddf, ppl can see you! Ask HelpMe who was on last night, and also it can be checked after Y"T.

[mmermss]

btw, when browsing ddf, ppl can see you! Ask HelpMe who was on last night, and also it can be checked after Y"T.

Who ever said  anything about ppl being able or not being able to see?

What should we ask HelpMe? It would be quite weird if he even held one day

[mmermss]

Who ever said  anything about ppl being able or not being able to see?

What should we ask HelpMe? It would be quite weird if he even held one day

Nevermind what i said...didnt get what you were saying...and dont see the option to edit

[satturn]

one day here! and i might have gotten the mitzva of oleh regel medaraiisa from my house!

[mmermss]

...as long as nobody - ABSOLUTELY NOBODY - can tell. For example, you can't turn on the light in your room, since people can see it under the door. But you can, say, browse DDF.

btw, when browsing ddf, ppl can see you! Ask HelpMe who was on last night, and also it can be checked after Y"T.

Just asked R' Wiener if one can do melacha very bitzina but people will find out after YT...he said best not to but if for a צורך its ok...so the question is..is DDF a צורך?   

[Saver2000]

Just asked R' Wiener if one can do melacha very bitzina but people will find out after YT...he said best not to but if for a צורך its ok...so the question is..is DDF a צורך?   

Why can't you browse without logging in?

[lfas25]

Just asked R' Wiener if one can do melacha very bitzina but people will find out after YT...he said best not to but if for a צורך its ok...so the question is..is DDF a צורך?   

Of course it's a צורך!   

[mmermss]

Why can't you browse without logging in?

Technically you can..but then you just cant post...

[Moishebatchy]

Tell people you're actually in Israel.

[rots5]

Just asked R' Wiener if one can do melacha very bitzina but people will find out after YT...he said best not to but if for a צורך its ok...so the question is..is DDF a צורך?   

did r' wiener say that?! lol :-)  so its u whose keeping the building hopping with nierasha questions...lol jk

[Galitzyaner]

I heard that there is a known Rav "Fisher" who's opinion is that people from chu"l should keep one day yo"t in E"Y.  Anyone with more info?

[PlatinumGuy]

I heard that there is a known Rav "Fisher" who's opinion is that people from chu"l should keep one day yo"t in E"Y.  Anyone with more info?

The chacham tzvi held so.

[L'Chaim]

 

The chacham tzvi held so.

And that's what chabad does.

[mmermss]

And that's what chabad does.

IIRC sefardim do it too?

[sky121]

I keep one day in E'Y as well.

[Achas Veachas]

And that's what chabad does.

That's not black and white, there are different Rabbonim who Pasken differently. When I was in E"Y for Yeshivah some of the Americans kept one day and those who kept 2 would ask them to go buy us Falafel for Seudas Yom Tov

[Moishebatchy]

IIRC sefardim do it too?

Yes.

[rots5]

The chacham tzvi held so.

+1 this is what my reebe said, theres a chacham tzvi - (when i asked him about pesach)

[Dan]

And that's what chabad does.

Most chabad poskim at least.  Though in Eilat it would definitely be 2 days.
And chabad Israelis will hold 2 days in chu"l.

In other words it has nothing to do with being an american/israeli but whether you are in the place where they held 1 or 2 days b'zman habayis.