Huh?? What are you expecting him to review exactly?
And besides, El Al's redemption chart to most short-haul routes is far better than almost any *A or Skyteam chart for that region. To the US, perhaps they're a bit overpriced. But they aren't a US airline and their not necessarily trying to compete with the US programs. Also, El Al elites get far more FREE last minute upgrades based on empty space in J (same goes from J to F), than elites on the other airlines on this route.
(I hope I don't get banned from here for defending LY...)
Agree, their prices to Europe, especially in the winter are quite good.
And even if prices to the US are similar to revenue rates, they often up a lot of availability, s/t that can't be said for the others. So for a one way, they're a great option.