Birchas Hagomel after flying

[Moishebatchy]

I do whenever I fly over an ocean.

+1

[Fan of Dan]

Who determines what's considered short? A week is actually quite long in my book!

Maskim for you anything over 3 days is considered settled down!

Interpertation I got is so long as you are still travelling, like going on a vacation etc then not to make, but when I went to Israel for months at a time I did make.

[Dan]

another new one, interesting.

[DH Data Recovery]

Also some don't say when the return flight is within 24hrs iirc

[jaywhy]

I had an old chakira, as the Halacha is u say tefillas haderech again every day you're still travelling, do you first say modeh ani, or first tefillas haderech. תדיר ושאינו תדיר, תדיר קודם

What would be the Havamina that you would say Tefilas Haderech first?

[Moshe123]

What would be the Havamina that you would say Tefilas Haderech first?

Read it again and detect the satire.

[jaywhy]

Oh I get it. Haha. 

[Achas Veachas]

another new one, interesting.

Hayom Yom (19 Tamuz) says that the Rebbe Rashab would say Teffilas Haderech (without Hashem's name) each day of his trip even if he was staying in one place for months at a time.

[Dan]

Hayom Yom (19 Tamuz) says that the Rebbe Rashab would say Hagomel (without Hashem's name) each day of his trip even if he was staying in one place for months at a time.

-1

[Achas Veachas]

-1

Whoops my bad meant Teffilas Haderech FTFM

[L'Chaim]

I only make when I return. For example if I go to Israel for a week I make it once when I get back home.

+1, but a week is already considered long.

[Mimi K.]

crossing a desert is like crossing an ocean. They are both from th "Arba Tzrichim Le'Hodos.
So if you do Oceans you should do Deserts.

I was told to make only when going to another continent over the ocean.

-1 what does a Continent have to do w/ anything? you can go to from Aisa to Europe in a minute but from LA to HI not? 
Ask again maybe you heard wrong. 

[Fan of Dan]

+1, but a week is already considered long.

Did you hear the same type of psak? What timing were you given?

[SGF]

Chabad Minhag is to bentch Gomel when flying over oceans, but not land.
As Dan said above.
[This, despite the fact that the Shitah of the Alter Rebbe would indicate that one always bentch, even when crossing land.]

i know a few Chabad guys that say it after every flight no matter how long.

@ Achas Veachas, do you know the makor? 

[L'Chaim]

Did you hear the same type of psak? What timing were you given?

No specific psak, כך מקובלני מבית אבא.

[Achas Veachas]

i know a few Chabad guys that say it after every flight no matter how long.

@ Achas Veachas, do you know the makor? 

The closest thing to a Makor I could find is Leku"sh Chelek 12 page 152, though that speaks about Tefillas Haderech. If you're %100 positive there's a Makor for a Hagomel I can ask my father

[SGF]

The closest thing to a Makor I could find is Leku"sh Chelek 12 page 152, though that speaks about Tefillas Haderech. If you're %100 positive there's a Makor for a Hagomel I can ask my father

i'll have to find out more about it, i heard its a letter in Igros regarding Hagomel

[SGF]

The closest thing to a Makor I could find is Leku"sh Chelek 12 page 152, though that speaks about Tefillas Haderech. If you're %100 positive there's a Makor for a Hagomel I can ask my father

In the same place it also talks about hagomel.

[Achas Veachas]

In the same place it also talks about hagomel.

My bad. I didn't look at the source, I saw it in Sha'arey Halachah Uminhag.

[dirah]

Excerpt from L'Man Yishmeu (Merkaz Anash).