Really strange. Seems the second option is charging you for the EWR-CLE leg. Maybe PUTPAC. or post a picture here of the ua.com page and let us take a look at it.
Shiz just booked (I) and left how long do I have to cancel/change?
I can give flight numbers...
Tlv-vie Os858 6/15
Vie-muc os111 6/16
Muc-ewr ua107 6/16
Ewr-cle (I forgot)
I'm gonna call know I'll let u know what happens... Doubt it'll be easy to lower an already booked award