Update. Two tickets in coach.
Doing Europe to TLV in the end. Did JFK-VCE via DUS on AB for 24500 avios ea, transferred amex at 35% bonus. 20ish in taxes.
FCO-ATH-TLV-EWR for 57,500 ea on United. High taxes for this due to connection in YYZ, hoping to change to the direct. Stopping in Venice, Rome and Athens for a few days each. Agent said the routing was not bookable, but the computer let me do it!
Any comments, positive or negative, appreciated.