Can you BBQ fish on a meat grill?

[henche]

Yes that is why I asked.

Ok fine. The core is G-d given, and there is a corpus of man made which surrounds it.

Fish and meat is part of the man  made corpus.

[Chaikel]

Thanks, funny story actually humans are not biblicaly forbidden.

Machlokes

I should start a seperate thread? This seems a good thread for this question.

http://forums.dansdeals.com/index.php?topic=16659.0

[henche]

Machlokes

Yah. Some hold it is an issur asei from the diyuk of את זה תאכלו, that we shouldn't eat people.
Some say it is d'rabanan.

But people blood is only maris ayin.

[Achas Veachas]

I hope I don’t open up the can with this one but are Jewish dietary laws God given or man created?

Leviticus 11 (just down the block from your sig )

Thanks, funny story actually humans are not biblicaly forbidden.

Machlokes
http://forums.dansdeals.com/index.php?topic=16659.0

Even those who hold it is De'oreisa say it is only an Asei.
I remember flipping when my R"Y mentioned it in a Shiur

[rots5]

Yah. Some hold it is an issur asei from the diyuk of את זה תאכלו, that we shouldn't eat people.
Some say it is d'rabanan.

But people blood is only maris ayin.

the question is, if someone eats his Cuticals does a person have to wait 6 hrs to eat dairy?

[CountValentine]

Yah. Some hold it is an issur asei from the diyuk of את זה תאכלו, that we shouldn't eat people.
Some say it is d'rabanan.

But people blood is only maris ayin.

I am glad I don't understand this one.

[henche]

the question is, if someone eats his Cuticals does a person have to wait 6 hrs to eat dairy?

Well, seeing as cholov isha is not milchig, it stands to reason that basar odom is not fleishig...

[churnbabychurn]

I hope I don’t open up the can with this one but are Jewish dietary laws God given or man created?

All of Jewish law in its entirety was given to Moses on my sini with six hundred thousand witnesses. One part of the law was transmitted orally and another written.
what's your question?

[jj1000]

All of Jewish law in its entirety was given to Moses on my sini with six hundred thousand witnesses. One part of the law was transmitted orally and another written.
what's your question?

His question was answered just read upthread.

[churnbabychurn]

His question was answered just read upthread.

just adding my two cents

[henche]

That was my gut reaction also, but we are forgetting d'rabanans

[CountValentine]

All of Jewish law in its entirety was given to Moses on my sini with six hundred thousand witnesses. One part of the law was transmitted orally and another written.
what's your question?

Do we have a copy of the written part? 

[rots5]

Well, seeing as cholov isha is not milchig, it stands to reason that basar odom is not fleishig...

only according to the taz and the MA bec something tamai is already assur and no din of Basar bchalav. While the Bach holds theres a new issur of basar bchalav by something thats tamai and that one would need to wait the 6 hours. ע׳ יו"ד פז

[yuneeq]

only according to the taz and the MA bec something tamai is already assur and no din of Basar bchalav. While the Bach holds theres a new issur of basar bchalav by something thats tamai and that one would need to wait the 6 hours. ע׳ יו"ד פז

You're getting mixed up between 87:2 and 87:4. No connection between tamei and cholov isha/maris haayin.

[rots5]

You're getting mixed up between 87:2 and 87:4. No connection between tamei and cholov isha/maris haayin.

i did not mean to continue onto his statement... Sorry. I just was stating an answer to my q

[jj1000]

You're getting mixed up between 87:2 and 87:4. No connection between tamei and cholov isha/maris haayin.

+1 that's what I was thinking. Still some do hold chalav isha has a milk like status.

[Achas Veachas]

I am glad I don't understand this one.

+1
You might start believing the blood libels were true
Though on a serious note it was sources such as these that were brought up in the Beilis trial as "proof" that Jews use blood.

[mek]

the question is, if someone eats his Cuticals does a person have to wait 6 hrs to eat dairy?

lol but since theres no issur of basar vcholov on say pork and milk only on food muter biachila so the concept of waiting wouldnt apply

[rots5]

lol but since theres no issur of basar vcholov on say pork and milk only on food muter biachila so the concept of waiting wouldnt apply

Not according to the Bach who holds you would by a davor tamai

[SamKey]

Not according to the Bach who holds you would by a davor tamai

wow your on a roll