UPDATE:
Went to Keter. Like ppl said custserv was nothing to write home about. They had 1 worker so he had to deal with 5 customers at once, which didn't help. They also didn't have prices on anything. I'm a Jersey boy so the hustle and bustle of Brooklyn didn't work for me.
nonetheless...
I went to Keter for the price and variety. I ended up getting everything I wanted, just not sure if price was actually good via other stores, but I was definitely happy with the selection. The only price comparison I had was that 1 Tallis bag I got was $85 (which I found out after I paid, and I might still return). I saw the same bag at Malchut later in the day and it was ~$100.
Thanks for the help!