I think Avis with A074800 is my best bet.
I can get a one way rental, return it in Manhattan on wednesday 1 PM, its only 215 USD, with the 70 Dollars I save, I can take a carservice to JFK and not have to shlep all my suitcases from the Avis station to the check in.
2 questions, what is this awd? Did it ever have to show ID? Is the price of 55 USD per day (without taxes) for a full size good?