you have to call AA and ask about what if anything is available on LY (ElAl) as you will need to do with most Programs
did you checkout what Delta wants?
Non-stops are DL (SkyTeam) 240 SPG might be enough for 2 Biz tkts,
CO but you dont have enough SPG since its 2 SPG per 1 CO
US out of Philly (I feel they have the best seats up front for the TLV run at least) its 120k per tkt and SPG is 20k for 25k US miles (U could drive to PHL or take a flight there from NYC, parking can be had for $7 a day off airport alot cheaper then LGA,JFK or EWR Lots but then I try and not park in lots)
ElAl using AA miles
Dont forget AC (AirCanada) if you do a NYC-PHL-TLV then no reason NYC-YYZ-TLV (havent flown AC myself check to make sure you wont get dinged with any surcharges)
so if you Only want NY-TLV non-stop youre down to ElAl with AA miles or DL