WARNING!!! DO NOT CALL WIDEROE OR US AIRWAYS!!!!!!!!
so, first ddf'er @sruli1234 found lag baomer tickets from nyc for around $750,
then @yoel found RT tlv-lga for $505
then i went ahead and booked for 04-29 05-29 for 377 euro and then booked for my family another 4 tickets for 1370 euro around june time, and then i saw....
LAX-TLV 379 euro dates:05-06 05-20
i am sure there are other airports and dates for around the same price or even cheaper!
good luck!!!