Maariv minyan at Yankee stadium

[Freddie]

"Doing" a minyan. read the post carefully

Whatevs, man. I remember you from the shaving thread. You have your own ranking system about which mitzvos you get excited about.

[doodle]

Whatevs, man. I remember you from the shaving thread. You have your own ranking system about which mitzvos you get excited about.

better than mindlessly following chabad ...
THINK dont just follow!

[Freddie]

better than mindlessly following chabad ...
THINK dont just follow!

You've got your own biases and they're pretty clear, kiddo. I guess you're the only one who's "risen above the matrix" though. 

[yesitsme]

Doing a minyan is part of the "culture" of judaism. its the SAME as Chulent.

correct
"מי שאינו אוכל חמין, צריך בדיקה אחריו אם הוא מין, ואם מת יתעסקו בו עממין. וכל המאמין, צריך לבשל ולהטמין, לענג את השבת ולהשמין, ויזכה לקץ הימין".
הסיבה לכך היא שכשאדם לא אוכל חמין (שדורש בישול בשבת) הוא נמצא בעצם מצהיר במעשהו שאינו מאמין בתורה שבעל פה וכי אינו מקבל את סמכות החכמים לפרש את התורה.

better than mindlessly following chabad ...
THINK dont just follow!

Who thinks more then chabad?
(better follow mindlessly and follow.)

[doodle]

to sum up my points:
No jewish kid belongs at a stadium ,
If you went, for Heaven Sakes , lie low, and do your thing , dont pray in public and act like a Tzadik,
 Prayer is your personal connection, its not about the 7th inning or the kiddush club,
 A REAL tefilah in private beats checking into a Minyan.
Dont blindly follow Chabad or any group And stupidly spout their opinions!!!!!       

[doodle]

correct
"מי שאינו אוכל חמין, צריך בדיקה אחריו אם הוא מין, ואם מת יתעסקו בו עממין. וכל המאמין, צריך לבשל ולהטמין, לענג את השבת ולהשמין, ויזכה לקץ הימין".
הסיבה לכך היא שכשאדם לא אוכל חמין (שדורש בישול בשבת) הוא נמצא בעצם מצהיר במעשהו שאינו מאמין בתורה שבעל פה וכי אינו מקבל את סמכות החכמים לפרש את התורה.

Who thinks more then chabad?
(better follow mindlessly and follow.)

a corruption of the B"HM, read it FROM the source.
Chabad is very thinking.  but if you follow anyone mindlessly you are a dumb fool!!  DIY

[Achas Veachas]

a corruption of the B"HM, read it FROM the source.
Chabad is very thinking.  but if you follow anyone mindlessly you are a dumb fool!!  DIY

I'm sorry! So quoting Shulchan Aruch is a Chabad thing now? The only mindless statements in this thread are yours! A few people explained pretty well why they believe davening with a minyan is a Halachah that applies everywhere, including the Yankee's stadium and all we got in return was some mindless Chabad bashing. Is that what Judaism boils down to for you? If you can't give a rational answer just bash Chabad?


FTR what does Chaba"d stand for?

[avromie7]

a corruption of the B"HM, read it FROM the source.
Chabad is very thinking.  but if you follow anyone mindlessly you are a dumb fool!!  DIY

You are out of your mind. I don't have time now to join the argument but I grew up disagreeing with chabad on many things I choose not to bring those arguments up and instead keep quiet, but of all arguments against chabad you picked one that makes no sense

[yitrap]

I'm sorry! So quoting Shulchan Aruch is a Chabad thing now? The only mindless statements in this thread are yours! A few people explained pretty well why they believe davening with a minyan is a Halachah that applies everywhere, including the Yankee's stadium and all we got in return was some mindless Chabad bashing. Is that what Judaism boils down to for you? If you can't give a rational answer just bash Chabad?


FTR what does Chaba"d stand for?

+100000000

[ChaimMoskowitz]

Dont blindly follow Chabad or any group And stupidly spout their opinions!!!!!     

What about following everything your LOR says? Is that OK?

[yitrap]

What about following everything your LOR says? Is that OK?

I assume its a serious question since this is already in JS

There is a concept called "Assey Lecho Rav" - "Create for yourself a Rabbi" putting aside people that a looking for an easy way out, if you are an honest god fearing Jew you make a calculated proper decision that this is a person that I respect and trust and I would like for him to be my rabbi and leader, once you decide that when you turn to him for advice of if he tells you something that you need to do then yes not only is it okay its required.

[avromie7]

I assume its a serious question since this is already in JS

There is a concept called "Assey Lecho Rav" - "Create for yourself a Rabbi" putting aside people that a looking for an easy way out, if you are an honest god fearing Jew you make a calculated proper decision that this is a person that I respect and trust and I would like for him to be my rabbi and leader, once you decide that when you turn to him for advice of if he tells you something that you need to do then yes not only is it okay its required.

His question was posed to doodle who seems to disagree with this

[yitrap]

His question was posed to doodle who seems to disagree with this

Oh shoot, I really wasn't planning on joining this fight

[TimT]

Oh shoot, I really wasn't planning on joining this fight

You gotta be in it to win it

[Aj3042]

Rabbis the concept of not going to non Jewish stadiums for their games is a very old one and is in fact mentioned in the gemara Avodah Zarah (I believe 17B, no Hebrew letters here on my computer). Now I'm not saying it's an outright issur (because you may be able to differentiate) but don't make it like it's some crazy new-found chumra, as it's not. The underlying theme there is that it's leitzanus, not even chukas hagoy.

[Achas Veachas]

Rabbis the concept of not going to non Jewish stadiums for their games is a very old one and is in fact mentioned in the gemara Avodah Zarah (I believe 17B, no Hebrew letters here on my computer). Now I'm not saying it's an outright issur (because you may be able to differentiate) but don't make it like it's some crazy new-found chumra, as it's not. The underlying theme there is that it's leitzanus, not even chukas hagoy.

I'm with you on that, as I said before, I was never at a sporting stadium in my life.

I don't think that's what the discussion is about...

[Aj3042]

I'm with you on that, as I said before, I was never at a sporting stadium in my life.

I don't think that's what the discussion is about...

Ya just referring back to before where people were making it sound like "there's nothing wrong". Now I'm not saying there is something majorly wrong but don't make it sound like there aren't issues with it as there clearly are.

[yesitsme]

Kosher Minyan ^tm

cap for hat
siddur with colored front page.........

[Achas Veachas]

Kosher Stadium^TM

FTFY

[doodle]

I'm sorry! So quoting Shulchan Aruch is a Chabad thing now?

FIRST YOU QUOTED SH"A THAN YOU ADDED YOUR OWN NONSENSE LINE OF EXPLANATION...