Rabbis Who Bash Dansdeals Master Thread.

[SamKey]

Why only mevatel issur asei, and not straight out stealing? Toess yehudy is assur.

You can't really consider this to be still on his reshus

I am floored at the positions some Rabbis are taking.

You were the only reason why I hesitated to post

[Emkay]

I would have thought they would be against anything where you had to use some type of trick. Basically if you can't be 100% honest then don't do it. Is putting Denmark as the country dishonest?

Saying that it's not against halacha isn't saying they are pro it.  I'm confident most mainstream orthodox rabbis would not condone this actual case if asked prior

[lunatic]

Saying that it's not against halacha isn't saying they are pro it.  I'm confident most mainstream orthodox rabbis would not condone this actual case if asked prior

That doesn't make sense... Either it's OK,  or not

[ChaimMoskowitz]

Saying that it's not against halacha isn't saying they are pro it.  I'm confident most mainstream orthodox rabbis would not condone this actual case if asked prior

That is an important distinction. That makes sense but now brings up a whole other set of questions for another time. TY!

ETA: oops I just seen lunatic's answer.

[Achas Veachas]

That doesn't make sense... Either it's OK,  or not

There's Halachah and then there's Ethics/Lifnim Mishuras Hadin.

[lunatic]

That is an important distinction. That makes sense but now brings up a whole other set of questions for another time. TY!

ETA: oops I just seen lunatic's answer.

Which is opposite...
I dunno. Maybe he is right

[Achas Veachas]

That is an important distinction. That makes sense but now brings up a whole other set of questions for another time. TY!

We have a thread for those questions

[ChaimMoskowitz]

We have a thread for those questions

The one I just started? 

[avromie7]

And departing from the UK is a lie? Huh?

+1

That proves to us that that he spoke without a clue of the facts

[ChaimMoskowitz]

That proves to us that that he spoke without a clue of the facts

You are departing from the UK?

[avromie7]

You are departing from the UK?

I sure would be there is no other way to do it just because I need to find a way to the UK doesn't make me not departing from the UK

[ChaimMoskowitz]

I sure would be there is no other way to do it just because I need to find a way to the UK doesn't make me not departing from the UK

If I asked where you were departing from for this trip, your answer would be?

[avromie7]

If I asked where you were departing from for this trip, your answer would be?

For that flight the answer will obviously be UK

[Dan]

If I asked where you were departing from for this trip, your answer would be?

UK of course.
If I book a ticket from ORD-SYD am I certifying that I live in ORD? 

[VacationLover]

That doesn't make sense... Either it's OK,  or not

So call it a "Bdi Eved"

[ChaimMoskowitz]

For that flight the answer will obviously be UK

That is not what I asked but I understand why you answered that way. All I am doing is pointing out there is usually at least two different ways to look at things.

If these tickets are honored most that will be using them will have a US city as departure for there trip.

[coralsnake]

UK of course.
If I book a ticket from ORD-SYD am I certifying that I live in ORD? 

Totally assur.

I don't fly anymore since there's no airport in my hometown. 

[avromie7]

That is not what I asked but I understand why you answered that way. All I am doing is pointing out there is usually at least two different ways to look at things.

If these tickets are honored most that will be using them will have a US city as departure for there trip.

And why does that make a difference? that is the way to book any ticket, who cares where I live or how I get there?

[lunatic]

That is not what I asked but I understand why you answered that way. All I am doing is pointing out there is usually at least two different ways to look at things.

If these tickets are honored most that will be using them will have a US city as departure for there trip.

That's the least of the issues. People piece together award flights all the time. Doesn't mean that they live in 5 cities... And nobody pretends to

[ChaimMoskowitz]

That's the least of the issues. People piece together award flights all the time. Doesn't mean that they live in 5 cities... And nobody pretends to

Do most people book one way cash tickets when they are flying RT?