Random questions.

[jj1000]

What is the reaction when an Orthodox Jew finds out they ate trief? Is it physical, emotional or both? Is there an example a non-Jew could relate to?

Imagine finding out that the delicious dinner you just ate was actually the family pet dog.

[CountValentine]

I would think it's mostly emotional (that could lead to physical).

I'm not sure if this is a good example for a non-Jew to relate to the feeling, but imagine doing something you believe is 100% ok and mundane, only to discover in retrospect that due to ignorance beyond your control you actually did something you consider repulsive and immoral.

I would then say an example would be to find out you ate dog.
ETA: Cross posting.

You said immoral, how so?

[Euclid]

Imagine finding out that the delicious dinner you just ate was actually the family pet dog.

racist much?

[Yehuda57]

Imagine finding out that the delicious dinner you just ate was actually the family pet dog.

I was going to post this clip: https://youtu.be/WR6d67O6478?t=195

[CountValentine]

racist much?

I have a brown dog so I am ok.

[ExGingi]

I would then say an example would be to find out you ate dog.

You said immoral, how so?

I am not saying that eating non-kosher by mistake is immoral.

Eating dog isn't considered immoral, and is accepted in some cultures.

I am comparing it to a mundane act innocently done, which later on is discovered to be really (almost objectively, but definitely in your own eyes and culture) wrong.

[CountValentine]

I am not saying that eating non-kosher by mistake is immoral.

That is what I was wondering.

[CountValentine]

When will you know what thread be moved to JS?

[Euclid]

When will you know what thread be moved to JS?

After the OK finishes releasing info

[Dan]

What is the reaction when an Orthodox Jew finds out they ate trief? Is it physical, emotional or both? Is there an example a non-Jew could relate to?

You're dating someone for a while and learn they were also adopted. You browse DD and find a deal on DNA test to learn more about your pasts.
Turns out that you're siblings.

[CountValentine]

You're dating someone for a while and learn they were also adopted. You browse DD and find a deal on DNA test to learn more about your pasts.
Turns out that you're siblings.

So Trump voters? 

[ExGingi]

You're dating someone for a while and learn they were also adopted. You browse DD and find a deal on DNA test to learn more about your pasts.
Turns out that you're siblings.

That analogy would be correct if one actually married.

[Dan]

You're dating someone for a while and learn they were also adopted. You browse DD and find a deal on DNA test to learn more about your pasts.
Turns out that you're siblings.

Naturally this now pops up in my feed
https://www.boredpanda.com/couple-brother-sister-dna-reddit

[CountValentine]

Naturally this now pops up in my feed
https://www.boredpanda.com/couple-brother-sister-dna-reddit

You hear these stories every now and then. Assuming true what would you do? What if you were married already?

[EliJelly]

You hear these stories every now and then. Assuming true what would you do? What if you were married already?

Almost impossible to happen to frum people today given the amount of info we can trace.

[imayid2]

You hear these stories every now and then. Assuming true what would you do? What if you were married already?

You wouldn’t be considered married any longer.

[Euclid]

Almost impossible to happen to frum people today given the amount of info we can trace, in any case an immediate Get (divorce) will be required.

אין קידושין תופסים I don't think they need a get

[EliJelly]

אין קידושין תופסים I don't think they need a get

Ha of course, edited mine. Tried to explain they'd need to separate immediately.

[lcm]

Almost impossible to happen to frum people today given the amount of info we can trace.

Another good reason why birur yuchsin should be done universally, even those the rav knows personally

[S209]

If he is not there all the time that is a disaster waiting to happen.

Isn’t this how health (and most government) inspectors operate? They randomly drop in to make sure you are following the rules, and the fear keeps you honest*. Same thing with tax audits.



*loaded word now, I know.