So Called Orthodox Jew Stabs 6 at parade in Jerusalem

[Shauly101]

 no words!

[shauly]

From YWN:

The Attacker is Yishai Schlisel who also stabbed people at the Toeiva Parade in Jerusalem 10 years ago and was released 3 weeks ago.

They couldn't hold him another few days?

[Aaaron]

Completely despicable.   

[AsherO]

It's already on BBC:

http://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-33726634

[Shkop]

Why is he a "so called" orthodox Jew? Orthodox Jews are able to sin.
They are able to stab people if they so choose. The parade in Jerusalem is
beyond sick, but he obviously had no right to stab anyone.
He definitively is Orthodox.

[A3]

Why is he a "so called" orthodox Jew? Orthodox Jews are able to sin.
They can even do horrible things like stab people. The parade in Jerusalem is
beyond sick, but he obviously had no right to stab anyone.

You mean he should be called 'pretend' orthodox jew?

[AsherO]

I think he's mentally unstable.

P.s. I wonder how many people would show up to Orthodox Pride parades in e.g. Tel Aviv and Manhattan.

[ChaimMoskowitz]

Why is he a "so called" orthodox Jew? Orthodox Jews are able to sin.
They are able to stab people if they so choose. The parade in Jerusalem is
beyond sick, but he obviously had no right to stab anyone.
He definitively is Orthodox.

I guess you are not shedding any tears.

[Shkop]

You mean he should be called 'pretend' orthodox jew?

Just an Orthodox Jew. Being orthodox does not mean that you can't be a rasha. Most of the Orthodox are
good Jews but there definitely are some that are not.

Yigal Amir is Orthodox. He killed a man. There are certain things that identify someone
as Orthodox. You need to believe in the fundamentals and accept halacha as binding. You may encounter types that
are orthodox but lax in some things unfortunately or some who mess up big time, as in this case. Being frum is a general
picture. Obviously a person can reject religion, but that is not the case here. It's a frum jew with serious issues.

[Shkop]

I guess you are not shedding any tears.

Nothing to do with feeling sad. I am just clarifying that the man is orthodox. Unless someone knows that he in fact
does not keep halacha on a general basis. Which is possible.

[Dan]

Who cares about the label?
Stabbing people makes you a bad human being and a flagrant violator of halacha with a massive C"H to boot.
There are civil ways to protest things you don't like.

[Aaaron]

Nothing to do with feeling sad. I am just clarifying that the man is orthodox. Unless someone knows that he in fact
does not keep halacha on a general basis. Which is possible.

I would posit that attempting to murder multiple people on two occasions checks the "does not keep halacha on a general basis" box.

[B.D.Da'ehu]

I would posit that attempting to murder multiple people on two occasions checks the "does not keep halacha on a general basis" box.

In truth, maybe. But unfortunately  in his mind this is keeping in line with the orthodox worldview.

[Shkop]

Who cares about the label?
Stabbing people makes you a bad human being and a flagrant violator of halacha with a massive C"H to boot.
There are civil ways to protest things you don't like.

Agreed. I am just pointing out that the term "so called" is wrong.
You can be religious and mess up horribly such as Yigal Amir or Yiravam ben Nivat

[doodle]

for the record: doing the "behavior" these people are "proud" of is punished by stoning.
It carries the most severe form of punishment in the Bible.
When Moshiach comes (Now! amen!) we WILL stone to death anyone who is a h*mo.
This man took the Torah law into his own hands. That was wrong. He must be jailed.
However the g*y paraders are wicked and wretched sinners. They deserve what they got.
(yes, this is not politically correct to say)

[doodle]

This man can be compared to Pinchas The Zealot . Who stabbed a Jewish Leader who was sinning with a harlot.
Hashem blessed him and his children forever.

[Dan]

This man can be compared to Pinchas The Zealot . Who stabbed a Jewish Leader who was sinning with a harlot.
Hashem blessed him and his children forever.

Are you nuts? Do you not know the circumstances that permitted Pinchas to do that? How in the world is a parade comparable to that??

[Aaaron]

This will pop just in time for Friday.

[doodle]

Are you nuts? Do you not know the circumstances that permitted Pinchas to do that? How in the world is a parade comparable to that??

i agree that a parade is not proof they sinned. and the circumstances of Pinchos require to be caught...
HOWEVER there is perspective issue here. why are we jumping on the man who took the law into his own hands??
these people are proudly marching that they do one of the worst sins in the Bible. When Moshiach comes g*y ppl WILL be stoned to death. YOU pray every day that Moshiach comes. so do I. 

[AsherO]

When Moshiach comes g*y ppl WILL be stoned to death.

Source?