Arab terrorist stabs and kills 2 in Jerusalem's old city!

[ilherman]

Withholding the bodies would be viewed as pretty barbaric.

huh? The bodies should be dragged on the streets. You don't think so?

[yitrap]

In previous attacks they didn't also big funerals/ at all

[David Smith]

huh? The bodies should be dragged on the streets. You don't think so?

No, I don't. Justice is for G-d alone, our job is to arrange the meeting. What would dragging the bodies on the street accomplish, other than furious headlines and inciting more Palestinian attacks?

[aygart]

No, I don't. Justice is for G-d alone, our job is to arrange the meeting. What would dragging the bodies on the street accomplish, other than furious headlines and inciting more Palestinian attacks?

+1000

The only way I would think that maybe it should be done is if it is clear that it would be a deterrent. Vchuli hai ve'ulay. While it may not be in the lav it is definitely against the concept of lo salin nivloso

[Emkay]

huh? The bodies should be dragged on the streets. You don't think so?

Nope I think they should just be buried with pork, that should def cut down on the attacks

[ilherman]

Well, maybe is it would make them loose the appetite to do terror attacks. I don't know. I don't know if its true but I heard that its known for them that if they are being buried with pork then they don't go to heaven. Well, if its true and they start doing it it will definitely stop them of doing these terror attacks since they don't go to heaven.

And personally who I watched the video from that Bezek worker ramming in to people and then coming out and starts stabbing right and left I just can't understand why there would be headlines condemning why his body is being cut up in fornt of video camera to 30 pieces and then buried ith pork. I would expect president oboma coming out and praising it...

[ChaimMoskowitz]

huh? The bodies should be dragged on the streets. You don't think so?

It depends if you want to be dragged down to their level. If that is the case I would just go St Valentines Day on them.

[springles]

http://www.cnn.com/2015/10/13/middleeast/israeli-palestinian-violence/index.html

here is an article (not the headline) that seems to be pretty biased.  I have come to expect it but just wanted to bring it up for CM who felt that if you read the articles then it gives an accurate depiction of the events

[ChaimMoskowitz]

http://www.cnn.com/2015/10/13/middleeast/israeli-palestinian-violence/index.html

here is an article (not the headline) that seems to be pretty biased.  I have come to expect it but just wanted to bring it up for CM who felt that if you read the articles then it gives an accurate depiction of the events

Article more important than headlines. It seems the article considers this a spat between the two. I look at as one side trying to get there way by murdering innocent people.

[ShlockDoc]

Makkos Yud amud aleph.

The gemara says it protects. Any issues have to be taken up with the One responsible.

Leaving aside your belief that God wrote the gemarah, if you seriously believe that the act of learning torah protects from harm, why do people get killed while learning torah?  (Not asking as a challenge, seriously trying to understand). 

[springles]

Article more important than headlines. It seems the article considers this a spat between the two. I look at as one side trying to get there way by murdering innocent people.

The official Palestinian news agency, WAFA, reported that "live ammunition" wounded at least five Palestinians at the Beit Hanoun crossing point Tuesday. This is after the 18 reportedly shot and injured the previous night at the Huwwara military checkpoint.

make it seem like the israelis are attacking the palestinians rather then defending the checkpoints that palestinians are bombarding with rocks and attempting to bring weapons past. 

where a man drove into a bus stop, running over three people, then get out of his car with a knife

a man? why not say a Palestinian?

And in the Armon Anatziv area of Jerusalem, one person with a gun and another with a knife boarded a bus and launched an attack.

they intentionally leave it vague to let uninformed people believe that maybe an israeli did this.

obviously an intelligent objective reader knows what is going on but there are not that many of those in this world

[jj1000]

Leaving aside your belief that God wrote the gemarah, if you seriously believe that the act of learning torah protects from harm, why do people get killed while learning torah?  (Not asking as a challenge, seriously trying to understand). 

Guys parents tell him to do shlucha kan and dies falling off the ladder...

[ilherman]

It depends if you want to be dragged down to their level. If that is the case I would just go St Valentines Day on them.

Well, you are going a little off here. If we were to get down to their level we would go around and stab/kill innocent Palestinians. Of course we don't wanna get down to their level. But taking a body from a terrorist and do what I said above is a very nice thing IMO. Just watch that 3 minute video where you see exactly what that terrorist does. You will say the same. I just don't get it. How can people have mercy on those people???

[ChaimMoskowitz]

Well, you are going a little off here. If we were to get down to their level we would go around and stab/kill innocent Palestinians.

Is Freddie around to explain my St Valentines Day comment? 

[shauly]

Leaving aside your belief that God wrote the gemarah, if you seriously believe that the act of learning torah protects from harm, why do people get killed while learning torah?  (Not asking as a challenge, seriously trying to understand).

The gemarah says that Torah protects. Maybe sometimes the protection is not enough? In the end of the day, Gd runs the world and the only thing we can do is to try our absolute best to follow Him as possible.

[Brian93]

שכר מצווה בהאי עלמא ליכא?
Anyone knows the sicha?

[skyguy918]

Is Freddie around to explain my St Valentines Day comment? 

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saint_Valentine%27s_Day_Massacre
?

[ChaimMoskowitz]

Ding, ding, ding we have a winner.

[skyguy918]

Ding, ding, ding we have a winner.

I can't imagine you were alive for that either - at that point it's just an historical event, not really about age. Some people are more into history than others.

[ChaimMoskowitz]

I can't imagine you were alive for that either - at that point it's just an historical event, not really about age. Some people are more into history than others.

Some of us watch a lot of movies and for some reason Freddie and I are on the same wavelength on certain things.