Agree.But not sure if you can invalidate geirus based on that..
why ever not???
and where do u get that she doesn't/didn't intend to keep all 613 ?
she sure is! halachaclly speaking if a jew doesn't keep one of the 613 mitzvos they are still jewish, but a geir/giyores that does not have in mind to keep every single one of the 613 mitzvos, that renders the geirus invalid. so she is therefore not jewish.
If you would bother having a look at hilchos geirus in שו״ע you would see that בדיעבד it's not so pashut(Even if we assume that immodest dress is a דאורייתא or that a דרבנן would also pose a problem בדיעבד)
Actually Rav Moshe specifically deals with this exact question of a woman who is being megayer (לשם אישות) and is not planning on dressing according to Halacha if בדיעבד her geirus is valid-and he concludes that it probably is valid (אגר״מ יו״ד ח״ג סי׳ קו׳)
I don't think the status of Ivanka's geirus is the topic of this thread. Go ahead and have the conversation in some comic thread.
FTFY
?
I don't think the status of Ivanka's geirus is the topic of this thread. Go ahead and have the conversation in some halacha thread.
http://www.tabletmag.com/scroll/198879/ivanka-trump-and-double-standards-for-jewish-converts
You guys are cracking me up, she's a damn goy, vaytur!
Be careful what you say- if she is Jewish- which she may very well be- you may be getting involved in מוציא שם רע, and are being מוציא לעז on her children (including Theodore James
just checked it, sounds like your right