I got this email too. Selected amazon gift card. Then a day later got the gift card from Cashstar. Clicked the view my gift card and used it on my amazon account to redeem. Then it said "Already redeemed to another account". Sooooooo, I was so mad and worried about my info probably out there and immediately called Barclay 1-866-928-8598 today (Saturday). I spoke to a rep and they said it is legitimate. They told me that "If you selected Amazon, it is on back order which is why it says that. You can select the other two offers now or they can resend you an Amazon gift card but since it is on back order it may take 7 -10 days to get. So now I wait for my new amazon gift card. Hope this help anyone. You must call them to get another sent to you. If you email them, I'm sure they will do the same but I like fast responses. But that's just me.