We'll have to agree to disagree.
-The tripadvisor reviews for the PH look very good and it's ranked #2 for Male, Maldives.
-The stays that I have had at Park Hyatt (Paris, Zurich, Melbourne, and Sydney) have been above and beyond anything I've ever experienced at any other hotel. The genuine service they provide diamond members is nothing short of stunning. They go completely out of their way to make your stay amazing. Free amazing kosher food speads, kosher wine/champagne, cholov yisroel chocolates, free rides to the airport in an audi quattro, free bike usage, etc, etc.
I would stay in a Park Hyatt over any hotel is that's an option.
-It may be remote, but there is a benefit in that. You are on your own private island with just 50 rooms. And the water is unspoiled and clear.
-The villas here are supposed to be made in a way that's more private than other locations.
And I would just rather use my 22K points and stay free and enjoy the perks of my top-tier status (free wifi, upgrades, etc). I'll stay in a Hyatt or Starwood before other hotels due to my status and how they treat me as a VIP when I stay there instead of just some Joe Shmoe.