Triangle k with grape juice concentrate ingredient

[ShlockDoc]

+1 especially when it comes to meat, there are serious Shailos about Traif there

My understanding is that the meat he certifies is kosher but not Glatt.  Is that no longer accurate?

[yuneeq]

My understanding is that the meat he certifies is kosher but not Glatt.  Is that no longer accurate?

That's what he says.
But that was never accurate if you are to believe anyone in the industry.

[Geshmak25]

Seasons carries motts apple juice products with triangle k.

[Freddie]

I can confirm about Hebrew National. Not reliable whatsoever.

[ShlockDoc]

That's what he says.
But that was never accurate if you are to believe anyone in the industry.

I heard it from someone who did research into it for a book. Not from someone who is nogaya bidavar like Rabbi Ralbag or a competing agency.

[ShlockDoc]

I can confirm about Hebrew National. Not reliable whatsoever.

What's the issue?

[george]

do they give hechsher on meat products? never saw. and i never knew this about triangle k either. i lumped it together with star k. 

Star-k is one of the major organizations that countless smaller hashgachos rely on, and is accepted in yeshivish circles nationwide.

[Iz]

Star-k is one of the major organizations that countless smaller hashgachos rely on, and is accepted in yeshivish circles nationwide.

Not by everyone...

[Freddie]

Not by everyone...

Let's choose our battles here, huh? You can't lump star-k and triangle-k in the same conversation. Not even close.

[Iz]

Let's choose our battles here, huh? You can't lump star-k and triangle-k in the same conversation. Not even close.

Agreed. I didn't say otherwise. If it was implied, it was unintentional.

[george]

Not by everyone...

That wasn't my point, and I never implied otherwise.

[Freddie]

Agreed. I didn't say otherwise. If it was implied, it was unintentional.

It came off that way in context. Thank you for clarifying.

[mmgfarb]

Seasons carries motts apple juice products with triangle k.

IIRC according to the star-k apple juice (from the US maybe?) doesn't really need a hechsher, therefore triangle-k would be fine for that.

[myi]

Every person has their own way about different hasgachas and what he eats and what not! (whether only kemach yashan or chalav stam or which meat and ect....) best bet would be to ask you LOR and see what he says ..

[mmgfarb]

Every person has their own way about different hasgachas and what he eats and what not! (whether only kemach yashan or chalav stam or which meat and ect....) best bet would be to ask you LOR and see what he says ..

What would be the fun in that? If everybody asked their LOR all their questions then we'd have nothing to argue about on DDF

[myi]

What would be the fun in that? If everybody asked their LOR all their questions then we'd have nothing to argue about on DDF

But regarding kashrus and what you eat is not dependent on what another eats! If he wants to know if the juice is kosher it is! But how machmir are you when it comes to hechsherim!
   Don't mean to stop you from arguing! Enjoy the argument, I will be going to bed now! לילה טוב 

[sams]

Not by everyone...

Besides for chasidim (who would put ou crc in same boat) who doesn't hold of Star-k?

[mmgfarb]

But regarding kashrus and what you eat is not dependent on what you eat! If he wants to know if the juice is kosher it is! But how machmir are you when it comes to hechsherim!
   Don't mean to stop you from arguing! Enjoy the argument, I will be going to bed now! לילה טוב

I didn't really understand what you just said but I was really kidding, kashrus is something that should really be dealt with individually with your Rav. !לילה טוב

[MeirS]

If he wants to know if the juice is kosher it is!

It this is the same authority that certifies Hebrew National meat, I wouldn't be so sure that the juice is kosher. I've heard stories from inside.

[Freddie]

It this is the same authority that certifies Hebrew National meat, I wouldn't be so sure that the juice is kosher. I've heard stories from inside.

That's exactly what I'm trying to say as well.