I just got off the phone with a CSR, and tried the following tactics (already got matched the 5k AU- got the points this morning):
1) Straight up match- didn't work, as all others have reported.
2) Asking to switch to the $125 AF card (as two others have said they asked via SM)- she said that wasn't an option that was showing for her, and that you can't switch products.
3) I asked if I could then apply separately for the $125 card (and have it in addition to the $95 AF card), since she said it's viewed as a different product. She responded that I could apply for it, but that I wouldn't get the points since I have the $95 card.
So...it seems like it both is and is not the same as the existing card.