We travel from the Left Coast pretty often to visit our daughter and her family in Bergen County, NJ. JetBlue's red-eye arrives at 7:05 AM (we come in Friday before Pesach this time), and usually use Teaneck Taxi. Overall, we're happy with them, but we often seem to be waiting 20 minutes or more for our pickup after calling them.
We've never used Uber, Lyft, etc., and I suspect these outfits would have a surcharge for the slow traffic around that time.
Anyone have a recommendation?